Best Of
Re: Oil to Gas Boiler Upgrade - Which Boiler to Choose?
Contractor is the most important thing. Lots of hacks around so beware. You could check Find a contractor on this site & post your location.
The decision is a choice between a Condensing boiler or Combi and a standard CI boiler.
Depends on what you have for heat emitters. Baseboard will not give you much better efficiency with a condensing boiler over a CI boiler. CI rads on the other hand are better with a condensing boiler.
There are a lot of issues that have separated contractors into 2 camps. The CI camp and the condensing camp.
CI lasts longer
Almost anyone (within reason) can work on a CI boiler
Less expensive install
Requires service less often and parts are available and less expensive
Condensing
More efficient (but sometimes not as much as they claim)
flame modulates (a nice thing)
May require more service and is more "technical"
Runs quiet
Some MFGs change models frequently
after 15ish years parts may be difficult to source,
As far as sizing you can size to what your Manual J tells you. No need to add for domestic water.
There are plenty of good people on this site that will comment from both camps so hang tight.
Re: Can’t figure out the banging noise in the radiator
The valves on that radiator suggest to me that this may have been piped as a two pipe air vent radiaator. One pipe generally led to a steam main. The other to another pipe which also had steam in it, but was intended to carry condensate back to the boiller as well. A return, if yu will, but not a dry return as would be found in later systems.
It works. Actually, in many ways like a one pipe system. However, pipe pitch — not so much radiator pitch — is essential to make sure that condensate can, indeed drain.
So that is where I would start looking. How does condensate drain? Are the pipes all pitched to allow it to drain freely?
Also make sure both valves are wide open…
Re: Cleaning a 130-year-old hydronic system before new boiler install - was it worth the 30+ hours?
Rust never sleeps , my friend! If O2 is getting in, and it is, corrosion will continue
If your boiler treatment has an oxygen scavenger ingredient, that will help. But it needs to be boosted from time to time.
Either a combination device, or two separates
Air removal is usually supply out if the boiler
Mag and dirt on the return side.
Can’t go wrong with Caleffi products. We pioneered the various separation devices, especially hydraulic and magnetic
hot_rod
Re: Manual J Heat Loss Calculation
I would also include the EDR calculation with the boiler manufacturer's recommendation for sizing according to the EDR. Just in case you actually need a 4 section boiler to get it to operate properly without being undersized (and the inspector will only approve a 3 section boiler that more closely matches the building load.) Unlikely but power can be intoxicating.
OR
You can always make the manual J come out to the BTU that you need it to, by increasing the infiltration number to 2 or 3 air changes per hour. You won't believe how that increases the load calculation numbers.
Re: Radiator Fitting
It might be easiest to just get another 1 1/2" valve to do the job in the place of the 90 ell.
We assume that this is hot water…..not steam?
Re: Wiring zone valve in Crown Boiler AWR series
Re: DIY questions tuning up my furnace
You need a combustion analyzer and to know how to use it to change the nozzle as well as how to adjust the burner. It isn't a DIY project.
Re: Manual J Heat Loss Calculation
Don't sweat it. Make good general estimates of al that sort of thing — no need to get carried away. Remember too that this Manual J is for the building code folks — since this is steam, you are going to size the boiler to the radiation anyway, not the building heat loss.
Re: Main vent making loud noises
I would say that is not normal, my Big Mouth is petty quiet last I checked it. Maybe the 'O' ring needs replacing.
Re: Main vent making loud noises
I'm gonna guess it's not the bigmouth, but the main dragging itself across a support or hanger somewhere as the main expands, or contracts, find the binding spot and slip in a piece of milk carton plastic to allow for a slipp

