NEW STEAM BOILER COST
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5ce90/5ce90c2272cde20fca55e4b293dc30fa23be7add" alt="JBB"
Does the cost of replacement increase to twice the cost of the boiler alone, with the near boiler piping and labor to do so?
Comments
-
Frequently more than 3X when all the piping and controls are considered. The boiler itself is not all that costly.
It's the labor and all the piping and controls that really add to the final cost. Could be 4X if the job is done really well with a drop header and generous sized piping (NOT 2"!!)
It takes 40-48 man hours to properly remove and install a new steam boiler with all associated piping and controls and startup and some skim. If it is not planned perfectly, with every possible needed pipe and control, the number of man hours climbs from there because it becomes multiple trips to the supply house(s)
The price per hour is depending on where you are located. Make your own estimate and calculate the total labor.
7 -
Much more than twice the retail price. Domestic iron piping is quite pricey and slow going.
And Labor rates depend mostly on the cost of overhead where you are. There you get what you pay for.
And if you can afford it, you should look outside the boiler room and correct any problems that hacks and time have invested into the system: Old mismatched painted radiator vents, leaking valves and ancient rusty wet returns. It may be the first time anyone's putting work into the system in eighty years.
6 -
Old rule of thumb from way back was to take the price of the boiler and double it.
That is not enough. Taking the price of the boiler and all the material needed to install it and doubling that may get you close.
Or the boiler cost x 3
Either way it doesn't matter. Labor prices vary from area to area.
Some installers do a great job and some do the old cut and slide.
You get what you pay for.
3 -
-
Christmas boiler job ?
known to beat dead horses0 -
I remember.
0 -
Unfortunately everyone goes on line looks at a steam boiler price and figures that there contractor is ripping them off and are usually just price or sucker shopping .No matter what math or mark up method one uses as always told to me by a respected plumber was every job is like rolling craps its lucky seven or snake eyes . The other Biggy is are ya getting a complete job ? Any fool can toss in a steamer and roll away but the truth be told as many may know there's a lot more then just replacing the boiler especially when dealing w old systems . Yeah guys prices are high but if ya include doing the rest of the work to put it back to the way it should work then your replacing radiator vents and either adding or replacing main vents . If ya dont want to return for free you will be wanding ,flushing and cleaning the boiler then firing her up and ensuring that all works that all rads are toasty and that the customer is satisfied . usually to make any sort of pay or profit in this day and age the pricing is usually a min of 3 x the cost of equipment and material and maybe you can pay yourself after all is said and done . It seems that most would rather pay less up front and complain either about the price the poor quality of workmanship the over the top fuel costs or the issues of upkeep on older systems which have gotten zero maintenance in 50 to 100 years . The greatest part is being asked on how long some ones mis piped mis sized 40 year old boiler that has seen zero service will last that by far is the best question ever and what can i do to improve on the situation its really a absurd question being i cannot see into the future . Even funnier is do any of these people go to the doctors and ask how long do i have to live and he say i don't know and they accept it but every body thinks where full of pooh and want it all done one shot mean while there milked into monthly dr visits and we feel like a door to door salesmen when we have to call and ask if they want there boiler serviced like money grubbers way to outta hand ,i stopped calling being they'll call when there's a bigger issue and after 3 or 4 years of no service im at a point that even if i did i the install im not interested being they have displayed a lack of trust and instilled a attuide yearly service is not necessary and that its just a money scam ,good for them you have found us out .lol
The biggest misconception about steam boiler replacement is any body can do it and it should not cost much this is why any company financing will always get the job no matter how wrong the piping is its all about the lowest price who cares weather its skimmed or that there's any main vents or 30 year old rad vents they just want the boiler .
Like written by dan i believe years ago i charge to even look at a steam replacement job and it has to be in my area not 1 hour away and it will cost so at least i am getting paid for another waste of my time by someone just price shopping for a low balling rube . i will say as soon as i state i charge for a estimate that usually ends 9 outta 10 calls which is usually fine by me ,tire kickers . But to be fair some times if there real close i dont charge and i go just for the s*its and giggles knowing right off the bat that unless doing for free i will never get the job but as i get older it s become less and less. It also seems the bigger the home the less they will spend so i tell the truth revealing all i see and never holding back ,tell them the truth and some times suggest to ripper out put in hot water or hot air some thing that requires zero home owner inter action and will not even entrain doing that job being there gonna spend 200 k on the kitchen and except to spend 20 g on the heat but bought the home for 2 mil completely brain dead .
Yeah this why i always end on this note cause its always needed
peace and good luck clammy
sorry for the rant
R.A. Calmbacher L.L.C. HVAC
NJ Master HVAC Lic.
Mahwah, NJ
Specializing in steam and hydronic heating5 -
Dont forget, some of us go out of our way to only use domestic pipe, valves & fittings (Made in USA)....big cost difference. Mad Dog
9 -
-
I've had a few customers say wow that much? I can buy the boiler online for cheaper. Yes you can! However do you have the knowledge, skills and ability to complete the installation? It all comes at a cost. True, I might be more expensive than another contractor. I choose to educate the customer so they can see the value in what our services provide.
3x the boiler cost is a fair starting point, but have some contingency money as well for like asbestos removal, chimney liners, radiator valves and condensate return lines, etc.
Owner of Grunaire Climate Solutions. Check us out under the locate a contractor section. Located in Detroit area.
2 -
3x the boiler cost is a fair starting point, but have some contingency money as well for like asbestos removal, chimney liners, radiator valves and condensate return lines, etc.
………………ducting to bring fresh air to the boiler room from outdoors……………..with fire damper
……………… 2.5" risers, 4" drop header……………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………removing cement encased 500g oil tank in an oil to gas connversion……………………..
………….…….removing and replacing 40' of 1" merchant couplings………………..repiping the HWH..no 1/2" permitted anymore………
………………..Installing CO detector with boiler shutoff…………
………………..Tekmar 279 in lieu of thermostat……………………………
…………………40' SS chimney liner………………8"…………………………………
……………….1" insulation on all NBP and 100' of 2.5"…………………………………………
………………..2.5" King Valves (2)……………………………………………………………………..
………………..timer to delay feed water for 12 minutes after shutdown……………
……………….. (2) Gorton 2, (4) Gorton 1, (8) Gorton 4, (10) Gorton 5, (4) Gorton 6..
……………..in NYC………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
6X cost of boiler.
-
4 -
-
-
@LRCCBJ NYC require CSD1 safety shutdown on residential installs? Only for commercial boilers in Michigan. I usually install a CO detector for good measure. Good points on the other items depending on what area. Luckily in the Detroit area the we aren't dealing with the added expense of oil conversions. Most of our stuff was coal well and that has been long gone.
Owner of Grunaire Climate Solutions. Check us out under the locate a contractor section. Located in Detroit area.
0 -
-
-
@dabrakeman . " Drawn clay liner" ?
Trying to squeeze the best out of a Weil-McLain JB-5 running a 1912 1 pipe system.0 -
Yes they would basically have something similar to a pillow cushion on the end of a rope. The "pillow" would start at the bottom of the flue right on top of the firebox and then a slurry of the lining material would then be poured down through the top of the chimney. At the same time the rope was pulled slowly up the flue thus lining the inside of the chimney with the material. Local chimney guys look at me with a clueless look on their face when describing the process. They all wanted to bash big holes through the plaster and brick above the firebox to stuff steel liners up for four times the price per chimney and then leave me with the gaping holes to deal with. Surprising to me because what do they think people did before there were still liners…
In the attached method "I" is closest to what I had done but it is interesting that they claim it to be one of the newest methods (maybe to them). Method H makes lots of sense to me intuitively for cost and flexibility and not having to bust any holes through the chimney walls.
1 -
Unfortunately everyone goes on line looks at a steam boiler price and figures that there contractor is ripping them off and are usually just price or sucker shopping .No matter what math or mark up method one uses as always told to me by a respected plumber was every job is like rolling craps its lucky seven or snake eyes . The other Biggy is are ya getting a complete job ? Any fool can toss in a steamer and roll away but the truth be told as many may know there's a lot more then just replacing the boiler especially when dealing w old systems . Yeah guys prices are high but if ya include doing the rest of the work to put it back to the way it should work then your replacing radiator vents and either adding or replacing main vents
Well, since it is Sunday morning and I'm just chilling out, I figure you deserve a response to this since it is eating you alive.
You are perpetually fixed on human nature itself. Only about 5% of the population has the brainpower to understand a complicated system like a steam boiler and make an EDUCATED decision what to purchase. Consider that sentence for awhile.
Now, consider how much of that 5% have the DESIRE to learn and understand the details of what you are trying to explain to them so they can make a truly educated decision? Maybe 20% of that group?
So, you face the prospect of educating and convincing, with the technical facts, of roughly 1% of the people you encounter who might need a new steam boiler. The remainder will have their eyes glaze over within 10 minutes of your spiel. They only want "heat".
It really isn't any different than people who need to get their vehicles repaired. How many of them can be educated to the finer points of vehicle repair? They only want the vehicle to move. The only difference with car repair is that they MUST HAVE IT NOW so the cost basically becomes irrelevant in their mind. They are not going to shop for the cheapest mechanic because the vehicle cannot move!
So, suffice it to say that your approach to selling a steam boiler is incorrect. Appealing to their intellect with regard to what you will provide, all the vents, the valves, the piping sizes, etc. is a non-starter…………because, effectively, they don't have any. These people operate on EMOTION. The most successful salesmen in the USA figure out a way to put the fear of god into the potential customer and cause him to go ahead with the project immediately.
Let me tell you a story about a company that sells the covers that go on top of a gutter to prevent leaves from getting into the gutter. They sell this $3.00 item (for three feet) for about $50.00. A typical house costs over $5,000. So, you would think that NOBODY would EVER buy from them and they would be out of business. But, they're not! You see them on the TV every day. The first part of their name is "LEAF". How can that be? The company is a master in sales and the representative will NOT come to the house unless both the husband and wife are present. He carefully scares the sht out of the wife with the potential harm that will come to the building without this product. They sign. The workmanship is terrible and they have no employees that do the install. It's all contracted out to others. Remember what I said about EMOTION.
So, in conclusion of my rant……………..the technical facts of the boiler installation don't matter one whit…………….it's putting the fear of NO HEAT into their heart that gets the sale.
BTW, most tradesmen are ILL-SUITED to be a proper salesman. They would be well ahead of the game if they utilized a good salesman to get the job. You would find that the 2% success rate would climb to at least 15%…………….AND, realize that the salesman knows almost nothing about a steam boiler!
And, I tell you with all due respect…………..you are a terrible salesman……………….because your expectations that the customer won't go forward due to price……………will spill over in your responses and the potential customer will feel it. Remember what I said about EMOTION.
4 -
@LRCCBJ fair 'nuff, but the boiler "tech" (salesman) telling Oma that she's going to die of CO poisoning if we didn't get a new boiler right now pretty much killed any chance of a "pro" ever servicing our systems. It was, however, effective in terrorizing an 80 year old lady. 🤨
So there is some small risk in that approach aside from ethical considerations.
Trying to squeeze the best out of a Weil-McLain JB-5 running a 1912 1 pipe system.0 -
There is most definitely the possibility of taking EMOTION too far and causing a backlash by the customer. This is what separates the poor salesman from a good one. Threats of immediate death rarely work but I assume he figured it might be effective with an 80 year old.
Every day I seem to hear how a scammer cons an older person out of a huge amount of money. Latest case was close to $100K.
Ethical considerations…………….did I hear that right…………..???
1 -
Ethical considerations…………….did I hear that right…………..??
I think we can all agree that trying to scare an old lady into buying a boiler she didn't need is a bad thing, yes?
So yeah, ethical considerations.
Trying to squeeze the best out of a Weil-McLain JB-5 running a 1912 1 pipe system.0 -
The lack of ethics in the quest for financial reward is the point I was attempting to make. Such behavior is commonplace today if you simply turn on the news. It is so prevalent that it basically convinces good people that it is normal behavior. So, their supposed ethics evaporate with various defenses.
How many people need to pass you on the highway doing 85 (in a 65) before your own behavior is modified to reflect this normalcy?
1 -
Sad, but true.🙁
Trying to squeeze the best out of a Weil-McLain JB-5 running a 1912 1 pipe system.0 -
where is there ANY enforcement?
The speed limits are a good example not enforced
We here all the time manual “J’s” are required yet oversized equipment on undersized ducts are the norm.
0 -
-
Some people have integrity, some have intelligence. The challenge is to find the ones that make your business successful.
- If you are a crook and a hack, we know what customers you seek.
- If you are capable and honest, you have to choose your customers wisely.
Competing for the same customer is a waste of time.
1 -
I do Commerical refrigeration and its pretty much the same. We're looking at a job right now that was never designed properly from day one. Unfortunately, I get the feeling they think Were ripping them off with the proposal for the fix!
0 -
How is saying a boiler should cost some multiple of the retail cost not a violation of the site's rules against discussing job pricing guys? 😅
NJ Steam Homeowner.
Free NJ and remote steam advice: https://heatinghelp.com/find-a-contractor/detail/new-jersey-steam-help/
See my sight glass boiler videos: https://bit.ly/3sZW1el1 -
Categories
- All Categories
- 86.7K THE MAIN WALL
- 3.1K A-C, Heat Pumps & Refrigeration
- 56 Biomass
- 423 Carbon Monoxide Awareness
- 102 Chimneys & Flues
- 2K Domestic Hot Water
- 5.6K Gas Heating
- 103 Geothermal
- 158 Indoor-Air Quality
- 3.5K Oil Heating
- 68 Pipe Deterioration
- 935 Plumbing
- 6.2K Radiant Heating
- 385 Solar
- 15.3K Strictly Steam
- 3.4K Thermostats and Controls
- 54 Water Quality
- 43 Industry Classes
- 47 Job Opportunities
- 18 Recall Announcements