Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
If you've found help here, check back in to let us know how everything worked out.
It's a great way to thank those who helped you.
honest question, steam or furnace?
so long story short, the installer of my boiler was an idiot, and now I'm paying for his stupidness.
the boiler I have is 238,000 BTUs, and my house in all honesty is like 112,000 BTUs. so my understanding is that i am just wasting gas and possibly short cycling.
so I'm in an impasse where I need to make a decision.
I'll be honest, I love steam heat. i would love to keep it but i need to replace my boiler, change the piping (since its like 50 years old and tons of rust everywhere) and i need to solve the air conditioning situation, (mini split/spacepak)
so i have the option to change it to a good old fashion furnace, which would have the AC and heat part.
the main question I have for you guys, would you recommend continuing with steam heat and replace all the pipes? (my house is mostly in studs now, so I have the chance to do this) (I have a few radiators that are in bad shape that needs replacing as well)
or do you recommend just go with furnace?
the issue is 1.) boiler install, replace pipe + space pak or mini split = 2 new furnace.
going with furnace just means any cookie cutter furnace guy can take a look and possibly fix, and since its so popular it will make the house "modern" or whatever. and 10 year warranty.
going with steam, I would need to replace the pipes and get a new boiler and get a space pak or a mini split air conditioning system. (the knock on steam is simple, finding good boiler guys are hard to find, the real good ones are all dead.) maybe a few years of warranty.
can i get an honest answer as to which i should go with? PS the steam system is the best when it comes to comfortable heat. i love it, but since my first installer was such a ******, now I have to rethink about what i should be doing.
any help would be appreciated. i know you all love steam, but i need to know what u guys think one should do. thanks