Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.
Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

Burnham boiler question

Options
2»

Comments

  • paulga
    paulga Member Posts: 23

    the manual says to increase the tstat setting by ~0.1 amp to avoid short cycling. how many F degrees on the tstat is equivalent to 0.1 amp in this table?

    image.png
  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Member Posts: 11,552

    Really????   You are looking at a commercial boiler that will never be anything like it in your home and asking about the type of pipes I illustrated to show you what type of tee fitting you asked about that you will never use and that is the reason you made a post asking about it?  

    image-9e50d2c537a01-e1fc.png

    If I knew that you look at everything so literally that I need to be very careful to be precise to the exact detail in order to make a point without you getting side tracked on something that you have no need to know.  

    I personally like to understand the reason why someone says something or prints something in  an instruction manual.  But you are taking this to an extreme that is farther than I have ever needed to go.  This illustration was a concept drawing not a precise engineering detail for you to follow (that you would not need to ever follow on your steam boiler).    The  point I made when I posted this particular illustration was to answer your query about the type of tee you might use in order to prevent bridging.  I also said that this does not apply to you because you will not be using a tee fitting at all in your situation.   

    In the future I will try to make my drawings more accurate for you so there is no question about what piping material you might want to use on your next commercial boiler installation. 

    Here is something that you may need to see for that next commercial boiler you install in your home:

    image-081f282ca223f-f4d4.png

    Does this answer your query about the type of piping you will use on the commercial boiler you will be installing?  It has iron pipes and I used actual pictures from the catalogue of pipe fittings and pipe nipples  I did not use the LWCO photo because I would hope that you understand that the LWCO location would be on the Tee Branch like I illustrated in my concept drawing.

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?

  • paulga
    paulga Member Posts: 23

    Thanks.

    I was not concerning the pipe materials.

    I was asking weather the joints of he pipes with elbows, and the pipes with the T (in that U shape assembly) are lead hubbed or tapped threaded. it's all hubbed, or at least hubbed where the two elbows tie to the two horizontal pipes (the other 5 connections can be threaded), right?

    I have had some experience with diesel fuel system, I'm just curious about the domestic water plumbing where things are different.

  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Member Posts: 11,552

    You asked "I was asking weather the joints of he pipes with elbows, and the pipes with the T (in that U shape assembly) are lead hubbed or tapped threaded. it's all hubbed, or at least hubbed where the two elbows tie to the two horizontal pipes (the other 5 connections can be threaded), right?" WRONG

    What does it matter? You are not using any of this on your boiler.  I would forget the stuff that does not matter and concentrate on the stuff that does matter.  Have you read the book yet? Do you know more about the steam boiler that you have?

    I was wondering about the water in the pipes, Did you get it all out? When is the gas company going to be ready to turn on your gas? Have you had time to do the maintenance that is recommended since the boiler is now empty of water? did you check the condition of the probe? Is the pigtail that connects the pressure control to the boiler clear? What lkind of pipe joint compound are you going to use to connect the pipes and fittings you remove to do the service work when you put it back together? by the way does the door bell work? Do you even have a door bell? What color is your mail box? Are there any letters in the mail box? Are they all junk mail?

    Just wanted to continue with the unrelated questions about the new home.

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?

  • paulga
    paulga Member Posts: 23

    Thanks for the reminder. I should blow all water out asap. I thought to place some temp sensors and keep monitoring the inside temp. The gas servicer has not filed the working permit yet. I complained to the city, hopefully Nationalgrid will call me about a timeline next week. I visit my new place every weekend. The plan regarding the steam boiler is to measure the probe this weekend, and bring my wrenches there in the following visit, I will also take a photos.

    i'm going to use rectorseal 5 when reassembling.

    when you say wrong, do you mean all 7 connections (each elbow has 2, T has 3) can be tapped threads?

  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Member Posts: 11,552

    @paulga queried: "when you say wrong, do you mean all 7 connections (each elbow has 2, T has 3) can be tapped threads?"

    Actually there are 11, you need a union to put that all together, and every pipe has 2 ends that are threaded. Two pipe to boiler, four pipe to elbow, two pipe to union and three pipe to tee. (I can nitpick too LOL)

    Every pipe on a steam boiler is threaded using NPT standard fittings an pipe nipples. I don't know of any better way to do that. Copper, sweat, ProPress, mega Press, hub, compression, flare and just about any other pipe connection is a sign that the installer/pipe fitter is not an experienced steam fitter.

    I have seen copper on wet returns and I find that acceptable, but anywhere there is steam, it should be steel or iron pipe and fittings.

    Does your steam boiler have copper tubing and fittings anywhere past the water feed system? All steam pipes should be steel or iron pipe/fittings.

    Untitled Image

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?

    paulga
  • paulga
    paulga Member Posts: 23

    i remember the system supply steam pipes are all 2" or 3" cast iron ones, on my steamer.

    now that you highlighted it, i recall the manual has a paragraph that disapproves using cooper for steam piping, mainly due to high thermal expansion and heat loss.

  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Member Posts: 11,552

    But you missed the important stuff… about the mail box!

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?

  • paulga
    paulga Member Posts: 23

    I have to admit I laughed. but I was asking how to set the steamer in vacation mode that provides minimum protection from freezing while avoids short cycling, it still has no answer either. this is very legit question, rather than a junk mail.

    EdTheHeaterMan
  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Member Posts: 11,552

    Vacation mode = set thermostat lower.

    It is that simple

    Your boiler will short cycle regardless of the temperature you set at the thermostat. It all has to do with oversizing. The funny thing about steam is that the steam does not follow the heat loss of the home. The steam follows the connected radiation. If you have 500 sq feet of radiation and the boiler is oversized by say 500 Sq feet for a total Net output of 1000 sq feet, then once the boiler fills with steam and the mains fill with steam and all the radiators fill with steam, the pressure will increase.  If the pressure goes above the cut out pressure the burner will stop. Once the pressure drops to the cut in pressure the burner will start. This cycle will continue until the thermostat is satisfied.   

    What does follow the heat loss of the building is the heat that leaves the radiators.  If the thermostat is set 40° above the outdoor temperature then the heat from the radiators will take a given amount of time to make the home reach that temperature.  That means that if it is 30° outside and you set the thermostat to 70°  your boiler will operate the same as if the outdoor temperature was 10° and you set the thermostat for 50° The short cycle will be identical in both cases.  Where you get the energy savings is having only a 20° temperature difference when it is 30° outside and the thermostat is set for 50°       The call for heat will happen less often.  

    I am not sure that your boiler is actually oversized by 100%, it could be oversized by 150% or more.   It may also be oversized by only 50% or less.  How the boiler operates will depend on what piping and radiators it is connected to.  If you want to solve short cycling for low thermostat settings you will also be solving it for normal settings. 

    This is over simplified but the concept is still there…  Don't just solve for low thermostat  settings, solve for all the time.

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?