Oil boiler has not been "de-sooted" in about 15 years. Bad?
Oil delivery sends a guy once a year. He changes nozzle, filter, and pump strainer.
A long ago prior owner had an access door built into the drywall, but it leads to a sheet metal side of the boiler. No idea how you can vacuum or brush from this side door.
Does it matter if nothing ever gets cleaned, brushed, or vacuumed ever again? Just nozzle/filter/strainer for many years. I'm not sure how past owners were able to get boiler vacuumed or brushed
Here is a video of the boiler:
Comments
-
You will find a series of cast iron clean out doors behind the large green panel on the right side of the boiler. You remove the large green sheet metal panel by lifting about 1" then pulling the bottom out away from the boiler. Now drop the green panel until it clears the top of the sheet metal cover once it is removed, you can slide the green panel to your left to get behind it
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
1 -
-
This.
If they're not even looking inside the boiler, they're just taking your money.
1 -
To clarify, I lift the side panel along with the top panel laying on top of it. Both are moving upwards an inch. Then I slide the bottom towards me an inch so the side panel is free from the top panel? But, there is no room to slide the panel anywhere. Do I need to lift it above the boiler, towards the ceiling, and stand it on top of the boiler?
0 -
Westchester County, NY. Not sure anyone does boiler service without an oil contract. Most are VC owned. I am using the same oil delivery as the prior owner, but the boiler service is just nozzle/strainer/filter.
I see the service tag says vacuum in 2010, and request to create access panel in drywall, so I know that brush/vacuum service was attempted to be done at some point
0 -
What do you mean by "looking inside the boiler"? It's not clear how to move the side panel, or if it needs to be vacuumed. I think they don't want to open the burner chamber b/c of the rusted nut. Just nozzle/filter/strainer.
0 -
To clarify, I lift the side panel along with the top panel laying on top of it. Both are moving upwards an inch. Then I slide the bottom towards me an inch so the side panel is free from the top panel? But, there is no room to slide the panel anywhere. Do I need to lift it above the boiler, towards the ceiling, and stand it on top of the boiler?
Lift the green panel as high as you can comfortably. Then pull the bottom out toward you about 6 to 8 inches. This will allow the top of the green panel to drop below the top of the boiler jacket.
the 3/4" lip at the bottom is how high you need to lift the green panel.
Then you pull the bottom of the green panel past the cinder block base and allowthe green sheet metal panel to drop to the basement floor.
Once the green sheet metal panel is on the floor, you can slide the green sheet metal panel in the direction of the blue arrows.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
0 -
@CoachBoilermaker, like Ed mentioned, that right side panel (with the hole) gets removed and there's going to be a series of vertical plates (3,4,5,6?) likely cemented to the block. Those plates get removed for access to the heat exchanger to clean.
The problem is, nobody wants to be cementing things that shouldn't be cemented. The bolts and gaskets for those plates are probably long gone. Some of the plates might be cracked, or missing hinges. People see that and know its a can of worms. They should just be honest with you, though. Unless they don't know what they're looking at which scares them even more. To do it right, new nuts, bolts, washers, and kaowool gasket should be installed. That takes time. That takes $$$.
An easy safety upgrade would be to junk that R8184G primary.
1 -
@EdTheHeaterMan Thanks for the diagram. I now understand.
@HVACNUT CAn you clarify about the cement? I never saw cement being used on YouTube examples of soot brushing. To brush a boiler, you need to cement it back sealed/closed?
Can you also clarify your safety comment about R8184G ?
0 -
Coachmaker. It is of the UTMOST importance that it gets brushed and Vac'd out. PM me. We handle this. Mad Dog
0 -
The examples on YouTube aren't using 60 year old boilers. The plates are likely also cast iron. The bolts rusted and snapped. There's probably soot on the insulation for the right side panel because there's only furnace cement holding the plates on.
The R8184G is an obsolete 45 second primary. Get one with a 15 second safety and interrupted ignition.
1 -
I don't really understand what you're saying. What bolts are rusted? I have never seen under the side metal jacket. Are you saying that once you slide the green panel to the side, the metal plates need to be unbolted? Are they glued into place? Cemented? Bolted? You are saying that every year, the boiler tech would have bolted and cemented the access plate under the green sheet metal after vacuuming and brushing?
0 -
I never seen cement used on YouTube boiler brushing. Are we saying that only old boilers use cement?
0 -
It's common to have to seal up old boilers like yours with furnace cement. You aren't going to see Steve Lav or anyone on YouTube working on an antique like your boiler. Does your company even combustion test the boiler? A good way to see if it needs to be opened up and cleaned is to check the draft loss. Measure draft over fire and in the stack and see what the difference is. And @HVACNUT is correct, I would absolutely recommend getting a modern primary control with a 10 or 15 second trial for ignition. Resideo R7284U or Carlin 70200.
0 -
I have not observed the boiler tech using combustion tools. Again, he just changes nozzle/strainer/filter.
So, you're saying my old boiler is a different design that modern boilers on YouTube? Modern boilers do not need cement? New boilers do not have access plates with bolts and cement?
Boiler tech once told me that the "fins" on this boiler are so big that it will never get clogged with soot, and therefore, it doesn't need to be brushed. I think he used nozzle 1.20 60degrees SS. I think he said it burns in a way that leaves little soot?
0 -
Can you explain the need for a modern primary control? What is the danger? 60 second vs. 15 second? Does this abort start up quicker under what scenario? Oil has run dry? Should I just have a totally entirely new burner installed? Will that include the modern ignition?
0 -
If for some reason there is an ignition failure Your old control will allow the pump to deliver 1.20 GPH of fuel for one whole minute. That's not an insignificant amount and if you press the reset button a couple times, well you can guess.
Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver
0 -
Just because your old boiler is different and gets sealed with furnace cement doesn't mean it shouldn't be opened up and cleaned. I carry furnace cement on my van and I wouldn't hesitate to open your boiler. And nobody should be touching it if they don't have combustion analysis tools to ensure that it's running properly. You need to find a better tech/company. It's ridiculous that a company in Westchester county operates that way. I'm in Dutchess county and we are much more thorough and focused on ensuring the safety, reliability and efficiency of the equipment we service.
1 -
@CoachBoilermaker this conversation scares me.
- you have an oil burner service person that does not use combustion testing equipment?
- you can't see that improved primary controls are safer
- no one has opened up that boiler's flue passages for more that 10 years when the manufacture recommended annual inspection over 50 years ago.
- if you can't properly maintain an old boiler, you should not own one.
Get something with a set of instructions that you can find on the internet and follow those instructions.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
2 -
Hi, I wrote you regarding this issue after sending me a message. I was wondering about how this boiler is working other than not being cleaned..is there an issue with that presently?…Furthermore I looked at the video and if you followed the instructions given the right side panel should have been removed and the access doors now can be seen. You won't be able to clean this out by using those doors only and you will have to access the chamber by removing the front cover which holds the oil burner to the boiler. The rusted area in left quadrant nut isn't tightened…is the sheet metal cover rusted or does this go beyond to boiler? Once you look at the chamber you can proceed cleaning the boiler.
0 -
The boiler needs to be cleaned vacuumed and serviced no doubt about that. Has to be done.
I don't think this is a dire situation and can be done by an oil tech that knows what they are doing. Problem is most of them are nozzle and filter changers and are lazy.
Any company that does not combustion test in this day an age is useless.
- get the panel off the boiler
- remove clean out covers
- brush and vac
- bolts may break but they are replaceable. The bolts are not threaded into the boiler. They just hook in place and held in by tension when tightened
- Clean the Clean out covers and the boiler surface. If the CO covers need new insulation that is easy Kaol insulation is easily available. Seal the covers and install with new bolts and red RTV.
- Vac out the combustion chamber , take down the flue pipe and clean and check that the chimney is clean
That is probably 1 1/2-2 hours of work.
Then set up and adjust the burner change nozzle and filter and pump strainer and combustion test and check all safety controls.
I t will be a messy job but for someone with experience its a non issue. The boiler you be checked next year. If it is ok you may be able to clean it every 3 years or so with a short check up in between.
1 -
@CoachBoilermaker, if @Mad Dog_2 says he comes up there, I'd take him up on it. He's as good as it gets.
3 -
Don't know if you received this email I sent..I see the comment by EDEBRATT-Ed and that sums it all up for you!
From what I see here you need to take off the cleanout doors on the right side of the boiler as Ed the Heaterman explained. These aren't bolted in…you tap them up and they come off. If this boiler hasn't been cleaned in 15 years you have to do more than that. You have to take the front cover off by removing four nuts and slide the whole cover out to access the combustion chamber. You have to disconnect the copper line leading to the pump and you may have to slide out the burner before taking off the cover if you can't lift it out without a problem since it's pretty heavy. Inspect the chamber and clean everything with brushes and vacuum it out.
I always had problems with this boiler with sooting up until something I changed. I would always use one of those blankets for the floor and back wall and I felt the chamber was just too big and I would get alot of problems. I then changed to one of those combustion chambers that are premade. This method contained the flame and works great. I use a 1.00 80 degree nozzle @ 100lbs pump pressure.
0 -
Not sure what to say. The average homeowner is not aware of combustion analysis tools or what a boiler tech is supposed to do. Is it common for boiler tech to not need combustion tools? I think he just knows what nozzle to use, and they use the same kind each time.
0 -
This would result in 1.2 fluid ounces being delivered and not burned. What happens then? Does it spill on the floor?
0 -
If you hit the reset button a few times and nothing ignites, the unburned oil can accumulate in the base of the combustion chamber. If and when it finally ignites it goes BOOM. Sometimes minimal damage. Sometimes, boiler doors blow off and soot fills entire house. I suppose it could be worse, but I have not been called in to those jobs.
1 -
- Correct. I have never seen the tech use a combustion tool. Just nozzle/filter/strainer.
- I do not know what primary controls are. Or what makes them safe.
- What are "flue passages"? Is this the big chimney pipe in the wall? Or the side panel that gets brushed? But yea, I am not sure the last time anything was checked besides the big 3 items of N/F/S.
- Correct, I do not know how to maintain a boiler. That is why I have the oil company send their guy. This is what 99% of homeowners do.
What instructions? I do not think my Delco DB-4S has an instruction manual online. But, isn't that why you hire a professional for? Or are you saying that I should get a new boiler for $25k since the current tech does not brush the boiler? Won't I run into the same issue with a new boiler?
0 -
Ok, so you also need to open the chamber on this boiler? The tech said he does not open the chamber on old boilers like mine. It's too risky, I think. So are you saying the boiler can't be cleaned bc the chamber needs to be accessed? This is not like Youtube boilers that can be cleaned from the side only?
0 -
I didn't understand the part about the bolts not being threaded to the boiler. What are they threaded to? Nothing? They are just rods?
I think you wrote a typo at the end. "The boiler you be checked next year"?
I am not really sure where to hire a shop that knows how to do all the extra stuff you mentioned. I will try to make some calls, but every time I've done so, oil delivery companies refuse to service clients without an annual contract. Do I call a plumber? A big oil company owned by VC? I'll make a list of demands, and see if I can find a company who understands what to do.
0 -
I'm pretty sure the boiler tech told me they do not open the burner chamber
0 -
With regard to your average homeowner comment above. I suspect the "average homeowner" does not know this website exists. I also suspect the "average homeowner" simply pays a professional to repair, maintain and or replace the heating system in their house. I am guessing that many of the homeowners that visit this site regularly read their manufacture's instructions and follow them closely. I have worked on many older oil burners/boilers, all of them suggest annual cleaning and setting them up with combustion analyzers.
In your case it sounds like the local oil burner technicians are not interested in truly servicing your roughly sixty year old boiler. I suspect the "professional heating companies" that visit your house may not own the required equipment to clean and service your boiler. This includes a special soot vacuum, multiple brushes, combustion analyzer, etc. We own all of it, but rarely use the cleaning equipment as we rarely service oil anymore. We do use our combustion analyzers often.
I agree, call @Mad Dog_2
0 -
Depending on how many time someone has pressed the reset button. when it finally does ignite it can it can make a pretty dynamic puffback filling the cellar with sooty smoke. It can burn for a while sooting up the exchanger surface. If there is a delay of say 50 seconds it can blow the flue pipe off of the breach or the draft regulator off of the flue etc.
Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver
0 -
you said:
Ok, so you also need to open the chamber on this boiler? The tech said he does not open the chamber on old boilers like mine. It's too risky, I think. So are you saying the boiler can't be cleaned bc the chamber needs to be accessed? This is not like Youtube boilers that can be cleaned from the side only?
I've cleaned that boiler,which is also the same Delco boiler as yours, quite a few times as well as others. You must know that I can do all this servicing and am able to analyze with equipment by myself. If you try to clean with brushes,etc from side all the soot and debris falls into the chamber.
If you stick a vacuum hose in thru the back door you might get some of the debris but for me that would be a halfbaked job that would result in alot of soot blowing around in the chamber resulting in inaccurate smoke tests,etc. Alot of new units have doors that can be opened up for inspection and cleaning and this boiler only has the back door and sides.
It's like a car. Most shops won't work on older cars in fear of breaking things and you see this with these extended warranties covering up to twenty years old vehicles only.
As I see it you have two choices here. If you are mechanically inclined and have the ability to figure things out and adapt to problems that may arise either by what you know or asking the right questions then go ahead with this.
If you aren't ready yet then take the advice of the experts here and have someone come in that can help you with this. If you take that route the next time you may be able to do this yourself. Be sure to let them know the situation…ask the right questions such as taking the front cover off,etc and get an idea of what will be done and if they've done it before.
0 -
After 64 separate discussions of your own and more than 400 comments on these discussions, I would have expected that you had gained a better understanding of the situation by now.
The fact that you are still unsure how to disassemble your own boiler, combined with the fact that the professional working on it apparently does not have combustion-testing equipment, raises serious concerns about how this problem is being approached.
We are dealing with potentially dangerous equipment, and I don't believe you have the necessary understanding or the professional support to safely address this problem.
I have made numerous attempts to help you, but I don't believe continuing these discussions is productive. At this point, I am going to step away and will no longer offer advice on this particular problem.
I wish you luck in getting it resolved, but I strongly recommend finding a qualified professional who has the proper equipment and experience to do the job safely.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
2 -
Thanks. I am mechanically inclined and have done a lot of automotive DIY. I however need to see videos of what to exactly do. Servicing the boiler myself is just too arcane and vaguely documented. I do not understand most of the terminology, etc. My goal is to get a boiler tech to do a proper service
0 -
UPDATE: The boiler tech came today. When asked about the side cleaning, he said boiler needs to be cold first. He did nozzle/filter/strainer and left.
Thanks everyone! This was a productive thread. We established the boiler can and should be swept from the right side. I might revisit this again next Fall. I will try to find a company that does full service.
0 -
mechanically inclined and qualified are 2 different things
Do i want Miss Vito working on my boiler?
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 87.9K THE MAIN WALL
- 3.3K A-C, Heat Pumps & Refrigeration
- 60 Biomass
- 430 Carbon Monoxide Awareness
- 135 Chimneys & Flues
- 2.2K Domestic Hot Water
- 6K Gas Heating
- 124 Geothermal
- 170 Indoor-Air Quality
- 3.9K Oil Heating
- 80 Pipe Deterioration
- 1.1K Plumbing
- 6.7K Radiant Heating
- 397 Solar
- 16.2K Strictly Steam
- 3.5K Thermostats and Controls
- 56 Water Quality
- 51 Industry Classes
- 51 Job Opportunities
- 18 Recall Announcements








