Wood Burning Insert vs Refurbishing Existing Fireplace

Options

Hey guys,

I am trying to decide whether or not to install a flush mounted wood burning insert or refurbish my existing fireplace. Had a level 2 chimney inspection and the sweep noted that I would need to redo the interior of the chimney approx $3500-4000 or I could skip that and do the flush mounted insert. I want an alternate heat source potentially but do not want to sacrifice too much aesthetically or be required by code to put a metal/stone landing over the brick that already exists on the floor. I have hydronic baseboard heat and ductless mini-splits for AC, which also produce heat. My thought is I might not need an alternate heat source if I simply install a generator to keep the boi

Fireplace 1.jpg Fireplace 2.jpg Fireplace 3.jpg

ler/mini-splits going in a winter outage. I have a tapered firebox inside the fireplace, but based on the dimensions I probably could get a medium insert in. I will get a another fireplace consultation but was wondering if anyone had any advice based on the aesthetic and dimensions of the fireplace.

  • Front width: 37″
  • Rear width: 26″ (tapered)
  • Opening height: 28.5″
  • Depth: approximately 22″
  • Brick hearth extends 26″ into room

Thank you.

Comments

  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,766

    sitting right in front of a fireplace you can get some radiant heat transfer

    They tend to pull heat from the space, while getting the air they need to burn safely

    A glass front helps, or ducting outside air directly to the unit

    You can still find some hydro hearths to add heat to hydronic or dhw

    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 27,996

    OK I'm confused. If your sweep said you need to redo the lining of the chimney… you need to do something about the lining of the chimney. I'm not sure what that has to do with the fireplace… which will still have to exhaust through the chimney…

    Can you clarify?

    The radiant heat from a well-laid fire in a fireplace is considerable (ask my cat). Is a fireplace the most efficient way to heat a room, in terms of amount of wood used? No, it isn't. A good airtight stove is better. Will a fireplace heat a room? Yes it will. Some do better than others…

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • Thanks Jamie- we installed a liner in the chimney for the boiler because the previous owners switched to natural gas from oil and never made the switch (flu gases were different temperatures and required different sizing). But, the sweep said if I wanted to use the fireplace I would have to redo some of the inside (I have to check the notes to be sure). However, we could avoid that if we just went with a wood burning insert with its own flu liner. I am trying to balance aesthetics of the existing fireplace with practical heat output, essentially.

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 27,996

    Seems to me that that is going to be a very personal decision! Any way you go you will need to do something about the chimney — either put in a liner for a wood burning stove or insert,, or repair the chimney to use the fireplace.

    As to using the fireplace vs. a wood burning fireplace insert vs. some sort of airtight wood stove… can't help you much with that. All three have their advantages. All three have disadvantages… for sheer efficiency in getting the maximum heat out of a cord of wood,, though, a stove with a bigger hearth is going to be the way to go. For enjoyment (and a surprising amount of heat) I'd go with the fireplace and repaired chimney. Not sure the insert would gain enough in terms of heat output to be worth the effort involved…

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • JMWHVAC
    JMWHVAC Posts: 136

    Do it right and get the insert. Make sure it has full view glass doors so you get the aesthetics of a fire. You will get much more heat out of your wood with the insert vs just the fireplace.

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 27,996

    If you want a fireplace insert which has glass doors why not get a wood stove with glass doors which really will heat the place? I would have suggested the Vermont Castings Montpelier II insert, but it's too big to fit in your firebox. Take a look at the Vermont Castings intrepid. Can be installed on a combustible floor with the correct accessories, and has a rear flue exit option which could tie into a liner in your chimney

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • Thanks everyone, I appreciate the help- I think the next step is to start looking into the specs of some of these.

  • JMWHVAC
    JMWHVAC Posts: 136

    When you get it done, post a picture with a fire going!

  • Bob Harper
    Bob Harper Posts: 1,192
    edited November 15

    You have a steelform fireplace that at a glance appears to be a Heatilator Mark C. You cannot install an insert into these things. It requires modification, which voids the warranty and listing. Steelforms have a very limited lifespan. They rust out, warp and were very often installed improperly. They should be removed and the fireplace rebuilt. This would then allow access to properly restore the chimney including an insulated large diameter ss liner to a parged smoke chamber. You can rebuild the firebox with traditional firebrick and refractory mortar or install a repair/ restoration kit such as Ahren Fire or a PriorFire. These refractory kits burn much more efficiently than brick & mortar, are more resistant to smoke spillage, suck less room air up the chimney, and throw off significant radiant heat. Their rear walls incorporate a special parabolic curve to maximize heat radiation. They also rate the fireplace at a zero clearance to combustibles for the firebox, smoke chamber and flue when properly installed with the smaller insulated ss liner and listed parging refractory mortar.

    To install a wood insert you would need the chimney to be relined, typically with a 6" ss insulated liner. The steelform would have to be replaced with an otherwise code compliant brick & mortar masonry firebox. A std. hearth extension for fireboxes 6 sq. feet or over is 20". All wood inserts require a minimum of 16" noncombustible hearth extension measured from the door seal.

    Please no pricing here but fyi the numbers you first quoted are consistent with a heater-sized liner in much of the country but nowhere near for a large diameter insulated ss liner with flue tile removal and parging the smoke chamber. BTW, nobody builds with throat dampers anymore. They use top mounted dampers, such as shown in your pics. Throat dampers are a major cause of smoke spillage.

    The Heatilator was designed to have fans installed into the two lower 8x8 air intakes and blow air through the convection chamber to pick up heat and discharge it out the upper two 8x8's. Have you tried it?

    Fun fact: The steelform fireplace was invented in 1927 by the Chemical Toilet Co. of Syracuse, NY and called the "Heatilator". It was just a steel shell built to the shape an old mason divulged the secret shape and dimensions. There was a building boom and too many masons had died in WWI so they needed an alternative. The steelform allowed construction of a fireplace by 'bricklayers' when 'masons' were not available. The next year they added the outer jacket and called it the Heatilator (we abbreviate HTL) Mark C. It ran in production until 1987. The breast warps and leaves a hazardous profile gap that cannot be properly sealed. The damper is non-removable on a piano hinge that rusts out. There is no approved means of transitioning from the top of the steel smoke chamber to a terra cotta flue tile and it always fails. HTL is now owned by Hearth & Home Technologies, the largest fireplace and hearth appliance company in the world. HTL fireplaces are still being built in Mt. Pleasant, Iowa. Their sister brands include: Heat & Glo, Quadrafire, Harman, Majestic, Vt. Castings, Monessen, SimpliFire, and their own FireSide Furnishings division that manufactures mantels and imports pre-cut sets of marble and granite to fit their fireplaces. The wood and pellet products have been lumped together under the Forge & Flame brand. The Montpelier II is the exact same stove as the Quadrafire Expedition II except different fronts. Both are constructed in Colleville, Washington at the Quad plant using castings from the old Vt. Castings foundry in Randolph, Vt, which HHT bought. Previously, Quad had been importing all their castings from Belgium.

  • stevetars
    stevetars Posts: 39

    Hi Bob,

    This is very helpful- out of curiosity, if the Heatilator Mark C is structurally sound and the chimney has already been inspected and repaired, is there any reason it cannot continue to be used safely as an open fireplace? And if not, or if it is no longer a viable option, are you recommending removing the steel firebox and rebuilding it as a masonry firebox using either Ahren-Fire or PriorFire restoration for ample heat production, rather than cutting the firebox to put in an insert because this may not be to code?

    Thanks again.