15-yr-old Buderus GB142, sealant on HX cover, rust, warm air leaking from cabinet - replace? And wh

Options
frozencombustion
frozencombustion Posts: 1
edited November 16 in Gas Heating

New England area. Buderus Logamax plus GB142-24 (aluminum HX), installed 2011, no known service history. The boiler feeds hydro-air coils in 3 air handlers (4 zones), plus an indirect water tank.

First service visit this week. Tech found:

- Red silicone-type sealant around the heat exchanger cover. He said someone sealed it because the metal must have warped, and that the prior technician tried to replace the gasket but the fit was poor so they had to seal it.

- Rust dust in the bottom of the cabinet and rust on a pipe below the boiler.

- Warm air I can feel at one spot on the back of the casing. He says the metal is warped and can't be fixed.

He didn't open the HX. He said doing so would cost ~$ and likely still end in replacement. ). CO alarm in the basement hasn't gone off. Photos attached.

Questions:

  1. Does this look like end of life, or is anything here worth fixing? For example, if the heat exchanger is bad should we just replace that instead? or is it just not worth it since it's 15 years old with everything else that can break later or if the part is no longer available. I asked this question on Reddit and someone said that it doesn't look bad, but again, the issue is that we can't get this serviced since the technician doesn't want to open it up (he said he didn't have the sealant handy to reseal it afterwards)
  2. For replacement, what is the recommendation? This unit is about 85K BTU/hour, I researched Lochinvar Knight, Viessmann, and IBC. Anything else to consider? This is our first time replacing a boiler, so I am trying to figure out how to suss out what a good company is and what are signs of a good installer?
rich text editor image rich text editor image rich text editor image rich text editor image rich text editor image

Comments

  • HVACNUT
    HVACNUT Posts: 7,823

    Its an obsolete boiler that's been poorly maintained. Replace it. See what reputable contractors recommend AND provide annual maintenance.

    SuperTech
  • Ironman
    Ironman Posts: 7,979

    What’s leaking is a dielectric union, it’s replaceable and not part of the heat exchanger.

    The boiler has been discontinued, but parts are still available.

    If replacing the union and cleaning the HX are all that’s needed, then you may wanna delay replacing the boiler.

    IDK why the technician said that taking the cover off would cost $1000. That’s nonsense: the boiler is designed where it requires no tools (except maybe a crescent wrench) to access and clean the HX.

    You may wanna look for a different contractor.

    Bob Boan
    You can choose to do what you want, but you cannot choose the consequences.
    mattmia2Grallertsukharev
  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,469

    there are a few leaky fittings there which all appear to be fixable. the question is if that money is better put in to repairing those leaks for another probably 5-10 years or use or toward a new boiler and i think i could argue that either way.

    sukharev
  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,731
    edited October 30

    I saw your post on Reddit. I'll say the same thing. That boiler can be cleaned but it takes a lot time. You have to repeatedly spray the heat exchanger with mineral oil and then reassemble the boiler and run it. They can get pretty nasty if they aren't meticulously maintained. It's a lot easier to clean most stainless steel boilers with a water tube or fire tube heat exchanger.

    That boiler might be repairable but it is 15 years old and they typically only last 15-20 years at best. It is an obsolete boiler and locating replacement parts might be a problem.

    Lochinvar, Viessmann and IBC all make great boilers. I don't recommend Navien. But whoever does the installation is a lot more important than what brand is being installed. The quality of the installation and proper sizing determines how reliable and efficient a boiler will be.

    kcoppGWsukharev
  • psb75
    psb75 Posts: 1,182

    That heat exchanger really should be checked and cleaned. It can get very crusty. The mineral oil spray and run method will work IF it is done on a fairly regular basis. Otherwise there is a LOT of "dental work" to do scraping the aluminum fins in that x-changer. I just "retired" one of these at 18 yrs. of service. It was a good boiler. Buderus AND Bosch are…"no more." Parts can still be "found". I replaced the boiler with a Rinnai. Very good tech support. Good boilers. Lochinvar and Viessmann too. Not Navien.

    SuperTechsukharev
  • One thing worth doing before you choose between Knight, Viessmann and IBC: get a heat loss done on the house. The old boiler's 85K tells you what someone installed in 2011, not what the house needs, and a lot of mod cons from that era went in oversized. If your real load at design temp comes in well under that, you want a boiler that can turn down low enough to cover it, or it'll short cycle all spring and fall. That can change both the size and the model.

    Since you're on hydro-air coils, also find out what water temp the coils need to deliver that heat. That decides how much of the time the new boiler actually condenses. A good installer should do the load calc without being asked, and if one just matches the old nameplate, that tells you something about them too.

    Mike, I build a Manual J app for homeowners.

    SuperTechsukharev
  • Big Ed_4
    Big Ed_4 Posts: 3,590
    edited November 10

    Butcher block oil is used for cleaning the heat exchanger not mineral oil .

    There was an error rendering this rich post.

  • Grallert
    Grallert Posts: 1,253

    Butcher block oil is mineral oil with vitamin E or wax in it.

    Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver

  • sukharev
    sukharev Posts: 9
    edited November 16

    I have same boiler, and it looks very similar in same area - rusted out dielectric coupling, normal for joining 3 different metals together. I'd recommend to keep it going till a more serious problem comes up. Mine had a fan failure, plus condensate bottle and exhaust leak. All fixed by buying $1K worth of parts, plus plumber time (I didn't want to take a risk of messing around with gas fitting myself). It's essentially a gas stove in a fancy wrapper. Parts are still available. I have planned out the rebuild for that rusty area, parked till warmer time. should be another $1K in really expensive pipes, new pressure sensor and plumber time. Beats $ I got quoted for new boiler.

  • GW
    GW Posts: 5,281

    If you're feeling lucky, throw some dough at it.

    Gary Wilson
    Wilson Services, Inc
    Northampton, MA
    gary@wilsonph.com
    sukharev
  • Do you mind explaining your comment? What exactly should we be lucky about? Old electrical, maybe? Or incurable leaks? And by dough, how much you think it's worth spending before it becomes impractical?

  • GW
    GW Posts: 5,281

    It's at the end of its normal lifespan. But it may go another 5 years. It's like flipping a coin. 1/2 the people out there would cut the bait and the other half will toss some money at it. The real bummer is when you put a grand or two into it and it acts up a few months later.

    Gary Wilson
    Wilson Services, Inc
    Northampton, MA
    gary@wilsonph.com
  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,731

    It's already impractical. That's a poorly designed boiler that's high maintenance, no longer being manufactured for a good reason. It's like sinking money into a rusted out old lemon of a car and expecting it to get you back and forth to work everyday safely.

    sukharev
  • psb75
    psb75 Posts: 1,182

    Buderus specifically mentioned using 'generic' mineral oil for the cleaning of the GB142 aluminum heat exchanger. They did not mention any brand names or "Butcher block oil." Interestingly, you CAN use mineral oil on wooden 'butcher block' kitchen countertops because it is "food safe". I would NOT use "Butcher block oil" on a mod-con boiler's aluminum heat exchanger because of the "wax and vitamin E" that HH member Grallert mentioned above.

    sukharev
  • sukharev
    sukharev Posts: 9
    edited November 16

    Heh, "impractical" is to sink $ for a 1 day install job on a $ new boiler. And perhaps that old boiler does have problems, but it's not a good reason to throw it out. New one will go bad just as quickly. 10 years is now the industry standard??? Now, be honest and tell us why you have come into the thread, and how many of these boilers did you actually try to repair instead of telling people to pony up the money for new one?

  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,731
    edited November 16

    I've repaired several GB142 boilers and spent countless hours cleaning those aluminum pieces of junk. Keep it running if it makes you happy but don't be surprised when the day comes that parts become unavailable. I can't see any residential boiler replacement costing that much money, I would get other estimates. Most companies will give you a free estimate. If you want a boiler that lasts a long time and is simple to service and repair get a nice cast iron boiler instead of a mod con.

  • It's not a gas grill you can just throw out. What you completely ignore is the whole system tuning cost, and the industry-wide push for new boilers. Once the boiler has an issue, they tell you it is done for. It's like the old car, sure, can get new one. Don't tell me this thing is too unreliable. It lasted 16 years, and just needs new parts and an expert who knows how to do his job. Everything I have read so far points at badly executed original installation or too much "maintenance", not the boiler. OP's original problem is hard water, maybe. His boiler looks great for its age. I found a boiler tech who helped me do the part installs. On deck for spring is more. Maybe not perfect, but it works, fingers crossed. And, with all due respect, how many of these did you actually try to repair once they had a problem?

  • No disrespect, can you actually tell us concrete details about what you think a direct replacement looks like and how much is a reasonable estimate? I have radiant heating, 9 zones + DHW. Standard setup, zone controllers that surely need to be upgraded too, full system purge, rebalancing, etc. It's not just a gas grill replacement.

  • pecmsg
    pecmsg Posts: 7,657

    how much is a reasonable estimate?

    That's a regional thing and why we don't discuss pricing

    SuperTech
  • Grallert
    Grallert Posts: 1,253

    You know it's really up to you whether you replace it or not. You have to look over the whole thing, what will go next, what's likely to go next. If the heat exchanger goes that's it. You could try and find a parts boiler or stock up on common failure items. If you're doing the work yourself that's great. If your paying someone to do the work that's a different story. You might find that a tech doesn't want the problems that go with trying to keep an obsolete boiler on life support.

    Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver

  • sukharev
    sukharev Posts: 9
    edited November 16

    "If the heat exchanger goes that's it". How do you figure? Have you actually seen one go? I agree, mid-winter you don't have much choice, unless you bought a spare ahead of time. But come summertime? Open it up, see. The whole thing is looking like around $ to replace, labor included. All subject to parts availability, and that's where you have to be careful taking it apart - top burner plate is the only hard one to find, but it's not what fails. And it's not life support, once you actually figure it out, it's same as old car - repair it and plan in advance. At some point total annual cost exceeds the new unit spread over 10 year life. Plus the breakdown risk. Read up, new boiler can break too.

  • sukharev
    sukharev Posts: 9
    edited November 16

    Again, no disrespect to anyone here trying to help people. Anyone trying to replace a boiler in Boston area, and probably nationwide, hits the same wall. Do the math. Boiler, top of the line, plus max 2 days of labor. I'd consider $ reasonable. Alas, no dice. A "Project Manager" would roll in, having no clue but quoting $ off the cuff, that is from their beautiful automated spreadsheet. Maybe some AI too. I could name the companies, but just take the top google hits. The funniest call I had was to Bosch. So, if you really want to help, send OP some contacts that can actually do the repair correctly and honestly advise on his boiler condition.

  • sukharev
    sukharev Posts: 9
    edited November 16

    By far most helpful advice I think. Except for the $ being too high. Plumbers in Boston area change upward of $ and for cleanup of boiler that hasn't been opened up for years, may actually be on a high side but reasonable if he actually knows how to do his job, and includes the union replacement. IMHO, once you get into that you discover that pressure sensor may need to go too. So, plan ahead and do it in summer when your back isn't up against the cold wall. And, FYI, top left, minor leak is another tiny part to replace, vents air out of the water line. Plan for that done at same time as the cleanup. And, once the box is open, you'd be able to assess the condition of the ignition components (all available and probably should be replaced, but if they work, may be not yet). Before you open it up, check the clips, they get corroded, stock up. All in all, a doable, real maintenance cost that should keep it going for years.

  • Buderus HX cleaning instructions here. I've done a few and it's not difficult, just have replacement parts - igniter, flame probe, air vent, etc. - ready.

    Considering how long they last, the aluminum HX's shouldn't be disparaged.

    And those dielectric unions shouldn't be there as electrolysis doesn't happen on closed systems. Oxygen needs to be present for ion transfer to happen and hydronic water is oxygen free. The gaskets in the dielectric unions deteriorate and leak; almost impossible to unscrew to replace the gasket because they become frozen. Often, they collude and clog and the leak stops and I just leave them alone.

    8.33 lbs./gal. x 60 min./hr. x 20°ΔT = 10,000 BTU's/hour

    Two btu per sq ft for degree difference for a slab
    sukharev
  • Grallert
    Grallert Posts: 1,253

    I've seen a few 142 exchangers go. Replacing one is a fun project. Like I said, It's up to you and your level of competence. Find a parts car/boiler

    Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver

  • Didn't say it's easy or necessarily practical. Car analogy only holds that much. Get the car wrong, you replace it. Get a heating system wrong, your house goes. That's actually one big argument for repair instead of replace. I looked at all boilers on the market, and sure, 10 years later have to have same conversation? Might as well figure out your current one, and give it a shot. Don't have to upend entire heating system that's built around the specific boiler.

  • @sukharev, we can't discuss pricing here and I've removed the numbers from your posts. Thanks.

    Forum Moderator

  • Big Ed_4
    Big Ed_4 Posts: 3,590

    Butcher block oil , all I can tell you , Buderus ( Tech support up in NH) has been telling me to use butcher block rather than mineral oil for cleaning the GB142 …

    P.S. I just called Bosch and mineral oil is ok to use …. I guess the warranty is over :)

    There was an error rendering this rich post.

  • GW
    GW Posts: 5,281
    Gary Wilson
    Wilson Services, Inc
    Northampton, MA
    gary@wilsonph.com
    SuperTech
  • GW
    GW Posts: 5,281

    cars and heating systems have a lot in common. If your 15 year old car doesn’t start in your driveway, not the biggest problem in the world. If your college aged daughters car craps out in the wrong end of town after the football game or concert, that’s more of an emotional pull, right?

    Same with heat- some people eagerly pay to have more peace of mind and don’t want to fuss around with aging equipment- that is simply more prone to act up. 5 degrees and no heat is the wrong side of the tracks.

    Gary Wilson
    Wilson Services, Inc
    Northampton, MA
    gary@wilsonph.com
    ScottSecor
  • Grallert
    Grallert Posts: 1,253

    If it were my boiler I'd repair it.

    Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver

    Alan (California Radiant) Forbes