Relays on steam boilers

Hello. I am reading and looking into the wiring of steam boilers. I am a bit confused in regards to the use of relays on simple steam boilers. I can understand their use on hydronic boilers where the 24 V thermostat is controlling the 120 V circuit for the circulator but steam boilers seem to use mostly 24 V on every circuit besides the transformer. Wouldn’t it be possible to wire the thermostat at the beginning of the safety circuit without the use of the relay and achieve the same result? I’ve been looking online and I can’t seem to find an answer. Help would be appreciated. Thank you.
Comments
-
Back in the old days, when thermostats were two wire, that was a fairly common way to do the job (though not the only one — sometimes the safeties were on the 120 volt power supply). Worked just fine.
Now we have fancy thermostats which require constant power to work. The call for heat can still be wired in series with the safeties, but the power to the thermostat has to be separate.
Br. Jamie, osb
Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England1 -
What relays do you mean?
NJ Steam Homeowner.
Free NJ and remote steam advice: https://heatinghelp.com/find-a-contractor/detail/new-jersey-steam-help/
See my sight glass boiler videos: https://bit.ly/3sZW1el1 -
-
Ok I am still a bit confused. So the relay is being used to separate the power being provided for the thermostat from the other loads on the circuit. But isn’t that what the batteries in the thermostat are doing? I was taught that thermostats are just a switch. Also lots of modern boilers in the install manual still include relays in the required install.
0 -
For example Weil McLain provides a transformer relay in the packaging. I have worked with companies who would disregard it, and wire everything with a separate transformer and no relay and the boiler would still function.
0 -
What is the purpose of an isolation relay? Im sorry I am relatively new into heating and trying to understand best as I can
0 -
-
You have to remember that there are — for the purposes here — three types of thermostats. Those which are simple switches and require no power. Those which have some digital electronics, but are battery powered (they often have a relay built in to provide the on/off thermostat contacts) and those which have more electronics, particularly wi-fi or similar capability and which require constant external power to operate (this category would include Nets and Ecobees and the like). These usually do NOT have real relays, but instead solid state switches (usually triacs) instead.
Now a boiler usually has 24 volt AC power for its various trim and safety devices. It is very tempting, for the third class of thermostats above, to use that same power supply — but usually the boiler transformer (or zone panel transformer) does not have the capacity to run the thermostats as well, since they take a good deal of power. In those cases a separate power supply is required for the thermostats. In most instances this is not a problem — but it is possible, in some installations, to get the separate power supply wired in such a way as to burn it, the thermostat, or the boiler electronics out.
To avoid that, use an isolation relay…
Br. Jamie, osb
Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England1 -
Hello eliasjj12,
There are probably thousands of different relay types and maybe even more applications for them. A relay basically provides isolation between two electrical circuits that are not directly compatible for a variety of reasons, different voltage or current is very common, switching and isolation are some more. Another example is a NEST thermostat being upset with the intermittent current draw of a Taco wax motor zone valve, with a relay the NEST sees the relay's coil current and not the wax motor's limit switch opening. With a relay one circuit controls the other.
" What is the purpose of an isolation relay? " Isolation, typically 24 VAC circuits are not directly compatible with 120 VAC circuits so it provides isolation and yet one circuit can still control the other. Otherwise for example how would a 24VAC control circuit control a 120 VAC circulator.
National - U.S. Gas Boiler 45+ Years Old
Steam 300 SQ. FT. - EDR 347
One Pipe System1 -
Looking at the Burnham Independence manual, it seems they used a relay to solve a few awkward situations with the probe type LWCO and other limit devices. If the thermostat was the very left most device (connected to the transformer) on the control and limit device string, when there is no call for heat the LWCO would shut off. Also with the actual thermostat connected directly to one side of the transformer and operating a relay's coil the thermostats that are parasitically powered by the boilers transformer will not loose power if a limit device opens. Using a relay resolves these issues.
National - U.S. Gas Boiler 45+ Years Old
Steam 300 SQ. FT. - EDR 347
One Pipe System1 -
Thank you all for the Reponses. I was not getting it before but now that it has been broken down for me i feel like a idiot for not being able to comprehend and see something so simple. Your Reponses all make sense to why a thermostat would be separated from the other 24v safety circuit. I have one final question in regards to smart thermostats. I have seen separate additional relays implemented on steam boilers in order to provide the constant common power required to power nests etc. Is it feasible to add the relay with the transformer that would be already included with the boiler, or would adding an additional transformer to power the nest be the correct way? In order words what would be your recommendations for adding smart thermostats to existing steam boilers?
1 -
Much the simplest way to add a smart thermostat to a steam boiler — or indeed most hot water systems — is a separate power supply for the thermostat or thermostats, and a simple (and cheap!) relay for each thermostat to send the heat signal to the rest of the system, particularly if it is an existing system.
Br. Jamie, osb
Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England1 -
-
@eliasjj12 , You are correct with your assumption on a 24 VAC operated Steam Boiler. As long as you have a simple 2 wire thermostat you do not need a relay. you just place the thermostat in the series circuit to break the line of limit controls like the LWCO and the Pressure high limit and the pressure operator control(s) The problem with many of the steam boiler OEM wiring diagrams is that the Thermostat is not the first or last in line with a relationship to the transformer. This throws a monkey wrench into the gear works of the smart thermostat that requires a constant 24 volt power supply with a common (third) wire back the the transformer.
Are you attempting to add a smart thermostat to your steam boiler? (or your customers steam boiler? if you are doing this professionally)
If the answer is YES then you have to safely rewire the OEM wiring to accommodate the thermostat to be the first or last "Limit Switch" on the series of limits that include the LWCO, the Pressure switches, any spill switches or roll out switches and the safety switch that is part of the automatic vent damper. The problem with that idea is that the probe type LWCO and the Auto Vent Damper that require constant 24 VAC to properly power their circuits, also require that they be the first or last on the limit circuit in order to properly operate. Since there are only 2 places that can be either first or last, that leaves no place for the smart thermostat that requires a Common wire back to the source (24 vac transformer)
So in order to make the thermostat that requires a C wire to work properly, you add a transformer and relay to the thermostat circuit in order to leave the OEM wiring as is and use the relau NO contacts to do the job of the thermostat while the actual thermostat can be wired as needed to operate properly.
Hope this helps to relieve any confusion on why there are so many RELAY posts on steam boilers for thermostats. Only on Smart thermostats that require a C wire to be connected.
YOU DO NOT NEED A RELAY ON A STANDARD 2 WIRE THERMOSTAT
Here is a typical Steam boiler OEM wiring diagram. See how the thermostat location is NOT connected directly to the transformer? If you connected the smart thermostat in the recommended location and connected the R to the side with the LWCO between the transformer and the thrmostat, when ever the LWCO did it's job as intended, the thermostat would get no power to the R terminal and that would cause an E72 or other code that indicates No Power to R terminal. that may cause you to need a reset in person to get the system back up an operating. If you are on vacation skiing in Vermont of Colorado when that happens, you may come home to frozen pipes.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
1 -
To whomever:
I have a relay set-up on a Riello F3 oil burner made by Honeywell. It connects I believe to the older model Honeywell mercury circular thermostat. The service guy for my boiler who installed it years ago told me the Honeywell relay is no longer available, if it were to fail. Question: what would be a suitable replacement available today, or can these Honeywell relays be bought used as a back-up? I could ask the service tech on next visit, but thought I would bring it up on this post for myself and those in a similar situation
Regards,
RTW
0 -
I think we may be a little confused here… the Honeywell T87 mercury thermostat is close to bulletproof, and very unlikely to fail. It only takes two wires. Now the question is, what do those two wires connect to at the boiler? Do they go to some sort of relay box, or do they go directly to the T-T contacts on the burner control?
Perhaps some photos of the controls on the boiler might help here…
Br. Jamie, osb
Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England1 -
Followup on my Weil McLain Steam boiler wiring.
@109A_5 found a Burnham steam boiler where the thermostat wire is the First in line off the R of the transformer here:
I posted this last January If you want to use the transformer form the Weil McLain boiler. But you must doublecheck your work to make sure all the safety limits are properly connected. Especially the safety switch on the LWCO and the Vent Damper open prover switch.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
1 -
Thank you @EdTheHeaterMan @109A_5 @Jamie Hall @Mark N. Everything makes sense now. No I do not intend on installing any Nest thermostats for any professional customers; however I may take on the project on my own steam boiler for hands on practice. I have had many many customers interested in adding smart thermostats however I would turn down the project because of many horror stories from co-workers dealing with smart thermostats. My experience is mostly with installing the piping side of boilers, not such much the electrical side though i have been educating myself slowly but surely with the knowledge from taking classes and studying. I appreciate all the insight.
0 -
One reason for using relays is to avoid the possibility of burning up or damaging expensive controls.
For instance, if you have an expensive control with sets of dry contacts a mistake in the field wiring with damage the control and it will require replacement.
By having the expensive control pull in a relay to do the same job a mistake in the field wiring will damage a cheap relay and not an expensive control.
I used to wire some automation systems and that is the way we did it.
Plus, I like having relays (like a Rib relay) with a light to show when it is powered.
1 -
Taking time to look as some basic electricity YouTube videos will help in your understanding of electricity and how it works.
Many plumbers and pipe fitters can get to understand how electricity works by using plumping analogy for form basic circuits. Like on a flashlight there are the three basic parts of the circuit. the Source, the Load and the return path. Without at least those 3 basic parts you have no electric circuit.
Source could be a battery in the flashlight. or the boiler in a heating system. The load is the light bulb in the flashlight or the radiator in the heating system and the return path is the wire that goes from the light bulb back to the battery in the flashlight and the pipes are the return path on the boiler system.
The tough thing for the plumbers to get around is the difference between the open valve and the open switch. the open valve allows water to flow while an open switch stops the electric from flowing. Once you get over that hurdle electric is easy as piping in a radiant floor system with 4 different temperatures and an indirect water tank.
Edward Young Retired
After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?
1 -
To Jaime Hall
I will post a photo of relay set-uop on oil burner - I personally dont touch anything on the boiler and leave that up to the old school service guy. Its true I do have that Honeywell model thermostat purchased just before they fazed out mercury
Regards,
RTW
0 -
-
I would like to see if we can take things a step further and make it even more complicated. Let’s say I want to add a nest thermostat to a Steam boiler. There is 2 wires in the wall located on the second floor leading to the thermostat. No easy access to run the 3 wires required for the common. I previously saw a coworker of mine install a -Common Maker- to convert a 2 wire thermostat into 3, shown in below pictures, to get a common wire connection for a hydronic boiler that already had a Common terminal on the motherboard. I'm assuming it is some type of relay of sorts. Would it be possible or feasible to use the diagram you guys provided above to get common power to the nest thermostat from the steam boiler, and implement the common maker with the rib relay diagram you guys provided to allow the 2 wires going upstairs to act as 3? Or is it a lost cause, and 3 wires will have to be run upstairs? Also in place of the rib relay, would you be able to use some sort of 2 zone relay to provide common power to the thermostat, as well as make the common maker work so new wire would not have to be ran?
0 -
0
-
-
Thank you all for the knowledge and advice
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 86.8K THE MAIN WALL
- 3.1K A-C, Heat Pumps & Refrigeration
- 56 Biomass
- 425 Carbon Monoxide Awareness
- 109 Chimneys & Flues
- 2K Domestic Hot Water
- 5.6K Gas Heating
- 105 Geothermal
- 160 Indoor-Air Quality
- 3.6K Oil Heating
- 69 Pipe Deterioration
- 966 Plumbing
- 6.3K Radiant Heating
- 385 Solar
- 15.3K Strictly Steam
- 3.4K Thermostats and Controls
- 54 Water Quality
- 44 Industry Classes
- 47 Job Opportunities
- 18 Recall Announcements