Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.
Wirsbo vs. Blue Ridge

Hey all. Looking for advice and first hand experience with these two systems. Looking at adding a multi zone system on the 1st floor of our colonial. I have full joist access and will be running the pex myself. Have a plumber scheduled to hook up the manifold/mixing valve to existing boiler.
Plates are the real cost of this setup and I’m wondering if I will really see the benefit of a more than double cost of the Wirsbo plates. I have wider joist bays and like the idea of the wider blue ridge plate and of course... the budget help. But don’t want to skimp if there will be an appreciable difference when it comes to performance. Appreciate your thoughts on this. Kind regards.
Plates are the real cost of this setup and I’m wondering if I will really see the benefit of a more than double cost of the Wirsbo plates. I have wider joist bays and like the idea of the wider blue ridge plate and of course... the budget help. But don’t want to skimp if there will be an appreciable difference when it comes to performance. Appreciate your thoughts on this. Kind regards.
0
Categories
- 80.9K THE MAIN WALL
- 2.5K A-C, Heat Pumps & Refrigeration
- 36 Biomass
- 394 Carbon Monoxide Awareness
- 2.6K Controls
- 1.4K Domestic Hot Water
- 3.7K Gas Heating
- 101 Geothermal
- 130 Indoor-Air Quality
- 2.3K Oil Heating
- 30 Pipe Deterioration
- 567 Plumbing
- 4.2K Radiant Heating
- 333 Solar
- 12.2K Strictly Steam
- 36 Water Quality
- 7 Industry Classes
- 51 Job Opportunities
- 7 Recall Announcements
Comments
Are you considering the omega plates or extruded?
Albert Einstein
Sorry, I don't have first hand experience. When we used plates, we went with another product.
Click here to learn more about this contractor.
Use the lowest SWT and constant circulation or ODR to limit wide temperature swings, if you go that route.
trainer for Caleffi NA
Living the hydronic dream
Albert Einstein
My hope is that radiant heat will be a better solution and will mitigate thermal rise.
But again. My specific question relates to the effectiveness of the 2 different style plates... do you really get the bang for the buck on the Wirsbo plates. They seem ridiculously over priced for a simple piece of extruded aluminum. Local advice I’ve gotten from pros actually walking the space say that regardless of which plates I choose, it will be way better than what it is now.
Thanks for the tip on circulation @hot_rod it’s a big old house, and I suspect the system will take a while to get to temp and will stay on pretty consistently to stay that way, so I’m hoping the tinking won’t be too present... but it’s also an old house, and a little bit of creaking is quite common (and certainly doesn’t bother us) anyway. 😉
No question the extruded cover these bases best.
https://radiantdesignandsupply.com/theheatexchanger/2013/3/4/comparative-infra-red-study-of-heat-transfer-plates
If, like Zman alludes to, the load is low then the less expensive, lower transfer may be adequate.
For best transfer, lowest SWT and noise free I always use the extruded.
trainer for Caleffi NA
Living the hydronic dream
What heat loss calculation method did you use? 36 btu/sq ft is likely double you actual heat loss.
Albert Einstein
I went back and read some of the conversations between competing brands/reps - and don't mean to relitigate the bad blood... but just want to know as a homeowner if the hype is worth the price in a real world scenario. I'll be doing the manual labor portion myself (with a helper) and will have access in perpetuity to check on sagging tubes/cold spots when and if they arise... But once the pipe goes up - as long as it's keeping the first floor comfortable - I won't much care which plates I used... But If I buy $2000 in plates and have to replace them with $5000 in plates because the $2000 dollar plates don't work... I'll be mad. Vice Versa - If I'm only paying for a name - and an energy savings that is going to take me 20 years to justify itself, then I'll just feel stupid.
I want to be practical and prudent... not flashy and cutting edge.
Keep in mind there are rooms and homes that cannot be heated by radiant floors alone. You may get some floor warming and require addition heat emitters.
1600 sq ft at a 70∆, I would guess around 40,000 or less load? I think your infiltration number is suspect?
trainer for Caleffi NA
Living the hydronic dream
Thinking I might try the omega plates for our master bedroom, as I will soon be opening the ceiling in the Living Room below for electrical and the plaster is shot, so I can easily run pex/plates and see how it works as a test. If it works well enough on the 2nd floor I can have confidence in rolling out the 1st floor. Otherwise I’ll know I need to invest in the pricey plates. Sound about right?
Curious about your meaning on “some houses” can’t be heated by radiant alone.
I really appreciate you guys taking the time. I’ll keep you posted on my progress!
B
I would suggest trying a different heat loss program. The US boiler one gives you very few input options. Have you tried slant fin?
Back to your original question, the omega plates may get noisy, especially if you run them at higher water temps. I think I would be comfortable with the less expensive option if you have a heat loss off <20 btu/ft. That is a SWAG based on experience.
Albert Einstein
https://www.slantfin.com/slantfin-heat-loss-calculator/
I would certainly do what you can to tighten up the home, a blower door test is really the only way to know that number. The more you insulate the more you save over the life of the building.
If the heat load for the room exceeds the amount a radiant floor can provide, it may not be a good radiant application.
Radiant ceilings and radiant walls are another option. Higher btu/ sq ft output and sometimes easier to retrofit. Thin plates work fine in ceilings and walls as they are encapsulated in the assembly, no movement.
PersonallyI feel radiant floors in a bedroom are a bit silly, much of the room is covered with the bed and furnishings. You probably don't spend enough time in there to appreciate the warm floors?
I'd do my next home with panel radiators, radiant floors in the kitchen and bathrooms only.
Panel rads with TRV give you room by room heat control, quick heat up, simple installation.
trainer for Caleffi NA
Living the hydronic dream
HotRod pretty much gave you the bottom line. I used the thinner plates in my first couple jobs, and have switched to the newer, much thicker ones. You could get by with fewer of them that put more heat into the floor.
There are buildings and situations where it just isn't practical to use them for all your heating. When I built our latest addition I planned on all underfloor heat, with the thick plates. I've adapted my plans, bought Caleffi manifolds, and am going with less of the plates, but supplementing with wall mount, thin European radiators. And also using some of the smaller wall mount radiators underneath our towel bar racks, to heat the towels, and the nearby tub or tile shower. Less expensive than those dedicated towel bar warmers. This is just an example of different ways to accomplish the same purpose.
Good luck.