Help sizing a gas boiler and hot-water baseboards for a cold second-floor apartment in Albany, NY

Options

Hello,

I need professional advice on sizing a gas boiler and hot-water baseboard heating system for my second-floor apartment in Albany, New York.

Room measurements:

  • Bedroom 1: 12 × 15 ft = 180 sq ft
  • Bedroom 2: 10 × 10 ft = 100 sq ft
  • Bedroom 3: 10 × 10 ft = 100 sq ft
  • Living room: 23 × 9 ft = 207 sq ft
  • Hallway: 6 × 6 ft = 36 sq ft
  • Bathroom: 6 × 6 ft = 36 sq ft

Total apartment area: 659 sq ft.

Ceiling height: 8 feet.

The bathroom will have electric heating, so approximately 623 sq ft will be heated by the boiler.

There is also a 6 × 6 ft space connected to the largest bedroom. I still need to confirm whether it is included in the measurements above.

Important conditions:

  • Albany, New York, has very cold winters.
  • The apartment is on the top floor, directly below the roof.
  • The ceiling/roof has insulation.
  • The house is detached, with exterior walls exposed to the cold.
  • There is a very cold, drafty garage on a lower level.
  • Keeping the apartment comfortably warm during extremely cold weather is very important.

Boiler I'm considering:

Archer Lancer LCR-3-068ANT, natural gas, cast iron, 68,000 BTU input, installed in the basement to heat only the second floor.

I'm considering a two-pipe hydronic system with 1-inch oxygen-barrier PEX supply and return mains and ¾-inch copper connections to the baseboards.

My questions:

  1. Is a 68,000 BTU boiler appropriate for this apartment considering the cold climate and exposed exterior walls?
  2. Would a 38,000 BTU boiler provide sufficient heating?
  3. How many linear feet of Slant/Fin Fine/Line 30 baseboard should I install in each bedroom and the living room?
  4. Should I use one heating zone or two?
  5. What water temperature would you recommend?
  6. What additional information is needed for an accurate room-by-room heat-loss calculation?

I want a reliable heating system that keeps the apartment warm even on the coldest winter days, without unnecessarily oversizing the boiler.

I will have a qualified professional verify the heat-loss calculations and installation.

Thank you for your recommendations.

Please show me the complete forum post before submitting it.

Comments

  • ScottSecor
    ScottSecor Posts: 1,096

    A lot more goes into a heat loss calculation. We also need wall, floor and ceiling insulation R values. Window size and type (energy values help too). Unheated garage? Any attic? Design temp (quick search looks like 1 degree F).

    Others that are smarter than me might suggest 40 Btu per square foot is worst case and 10 Btu per square foot best case.

    Mad Dog_2
  • pecmsg
    pecmsg Posts: 7,664

    Manual "J" calculation will tell you the heat loss of the 2nd floor. Rough calculations are available online. More accurate ones come with a price tag.

    Mad Dog_2
  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,821

    659x a middle of the road 25 btu/ ft estimate is 16,000 btu/hr

    With heated space below, the number could be lower.

    A load calc is the only way to get a more accurate number

    The challenge for small space loads is finding a small enough boiler.
    A 50,000 mod con turns down to around 8,000 btu/hr. That is a good option as the are sealed combustion, no combustion air grills needed, they come with outdoor reset.

    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
    mattmia2
  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,487
    edited 6:26PM

    the answer to the boiler is probably the smallest boiler you can find, ideally a mod con as @hot_rod alluded to.

    the heat loss calculations are pretty important here in sizing the emitters to balance the system. if you need multiple zones depends on how you want to use the space although zoning could make the smallest mod con that is already too big unhappy if the zones are too small and could be complicated with a conventional boiler. if you do a lot of cooking that makes the kitchen sometimes hot and some times cold or if you want the bedrooms warmer or cooler then you might want to look at zoning. is there space with a lot of solar gain? thermostatic radiator valves and a system that is designed for them might be a better option to deal with variations in heat loss in a space this small.