Cracked heat exchanger?

Options

I just had a tune up done on my Trane mid efficiency furnace (from 2004). The tech said everything is running fine except for this cracked heat exchanger:

IMG_3958-EEC6C566-A727-4C71-A0C5-2DC7541A6835_compressed.jpg IMG_3959-1290A875-B61F-431A-A1B2-57D1A13436E2_compressed.jpg

I looked up cracked heat exchanges online and those look quite different. Is the one in my furnace an early crack? If the rest of the inspection didn't find anything, does my furnace need a replacement sooner than later as the tech recommended?

Thanks in advance.

Comments

  • pecmsg
    pecmsg Posts: 7,664
    edited November 20

    get a second opinion


    a model # would help also

  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,734

    I don't like the look of it, it looks like some sort of defect. Did the tech do a combustion analysis? I'd be interested in the results. Did he contact Trane and get their opinion? Is the furnace still functioning normally?

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,402

    Good thing you have a tech interested enough to look for a problem. I would get a 2d opinion, but I think you need a new furnace. You don't want CO in the house.

  • Hard for anyone to call it from a photo. I'd ask the tech to show you the spot in person and say what they saw besides the look of it, and have the second person check it the same way.

    On replacing, the crack is what matters, the rest of the inspection being fine doesn't change much. The heat exchanger is the part that keeps the combustion gases, CO included, out of the air the blower sends around the house, so if a second tech confirms it I wouldn't keep running it long. Yours is also 22 years old, past the 15 to 20 years the makers give for a gas furnace.

    Until it's sorted, make sure you have working CO alarms on every level and near the bedrooms.

    One more thing before you buy anything: put the serial number in Trane's warranty lookup. A 20 year heat exchanger warranty would be over on yours, but some Trane models carry a lifetime one for a registered original owner, so it's worth a minute.

  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,487

    that looks more like a seam between 2 pieced of the hx/collector box rather than a crack. you'd need to know more about how the hx is assembled, it could be sealed with a gasket or adhesive beyond that seam. nothing there looks remotely rusty, might even be stainless or plastic.

  • HVACNUT
    HVACNUT Posts: 7,838

    Screenshot_20261121_082444_Samsung Browser.jpg

    To me it doesn't look like a crack as much as a divot. Besides, its at the entry or exit. Its not in the air stream.