Stinky oil boiler

Options

Not sure where to turn here. Oil company, hvac company and plumber all have come up short. We’ve been getting oil exhaust smell in our basement when the boiler is cranking good, most specifically when hot water is going for back to back showers. Has been happening for a couple years but only once or twice a winter. Now it also all the time. Oil company will not sell me a new boiler, says I don’t need it.

system.

  • Peerless boiler with riello burner. 22 years old
  • Vents from basement thru garage into an outside wall chimney. Induction fan installed by previous owners.

Work done in order.

  • Cleaning x2
  • Replaced exhaust flue, tape seems, insulate to increase draft. Flue pipe was rotted out. Hope was in increase draft with hotter pipe.
  • air adjust
  • oil company owner son came out, discovered they broke the chamber during the clean. Replaced. This helped a ton. He discovered a back draft issue when the kitchen fan is turned up upstairs. Almost zero smell after this repair, expect when fan or dyer was running upstairs or it was super windy outside
  • fresh air intake added to the basement with a ‘fan in a can’ to eliminate the backdraft issue. Unfortunately the Smell back, pretty bad this morning. After we started up the heat downstairs and kids took 3 showers. Heat gets dropped at night to 60, we run a heat pump yesterday with these ‘mild temp’ so it was cooler start up.


IMG_6669.jpeg IMG_6609.jpeg IMG_6606.jpeg

Comments

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,352

    reducing the firing rate slightly might help. Post combustion report if you have one.

  • JUGHNE
    JUGHNE Posts: 11,657

    Is that a "Fan in a Can" in the corner for combustion air?

    Where does it get its air outside?

    Picture of the inlet if possible?

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 27,996

    Dumb question maybe. I notice a draught regulator damper on the exhaust. How open is it when the boiler is running (it's closed in the picture)?

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • Your flue pipe, thru the drywall, next to the studs violates code.
    I don't see any combustion numbers.
    Is it possible there is some gasketing material missing. Specifically under the top of the unit, where the cleanout plate is located.
    Are you sure you solved your depressurization issue?
    How far is the horizontal run in the flue pipe & how high is the chimney? You may simply have a bad design, combined with that deep set back and very cold flue on start up.
    Although the Riello is a nice burner, a Beckett with a longer pre-purge and a long post purge might help.

  • IMG_6683.jpeg

    Here it is. Realized they wore Becker burner is an obvious typo on their end.

  • Yes they thought it needed more air/wanted to pressurize the basement. 25-30 duct run thru the garage to an outside wall.

    here’s the route and intake vent

    IMG_6680.jpeg

    IMG_6679.jpeg
  • semi open. We’ve tried very open, not open seems to smell less

  • it’s there’s a large insulation air space at the drywall.

    The bad routing was brought up by all three folks. Reason for the insulation was trying to over come this. Been in our for 8 years and hasn’t been a issue like this till this year

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 27,996

    Realistically, there are only two ways you can get a smell from an oil burner: either there is inadequate draught on the chimney or stack, or inadequate combustion air getting in. I asked about the draught damper, as if there is adequate stack draught it should be slightly open even with the burner off — and reasonably open with the burner on. If it isn't, that tells you that there is inadequate draught in the stack or chimney or that the house is depressurized relative to outside. May take some tracking down.

    The fan in a can may help — provided it is turned on at the start of the burner pre-purge (if any) and in fad preferably earlier — provided it's big enough to compensate for any other exhaust fans or the like.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • thanks. Can in the can kicks on 3-5 seconds prior to fire up. Then the induction fan for a seconds, then fires up. Damper doesn’t move until the induction fan kicks on. They put a screw in it to try and keep it shut closed, not sure if that helps or hurts.

    The can-fan is on the low setting, maybe it needs to be bumped up.

    Bathrooms fan was going today in the bathroom but that was on the second floor. Though it’s a nice 110cfm fan it’s a long way to affect the basement ?

    Heat pump upstairs was also going (ducted in the attic) but that’s tight as a nats ****, had a sub from work do it that does all hospital work.

  • HVACNUT
    HVACNUT Posts: 7,802

    Has the flue been inspected? There's a cap to inspect the base.

    That looks about a 12 ft horizontal run on the flue. I'd like to see what the draft is without the inducer. I find it hard to believe its only -.01,-.03 with a booster. If there was a need for the booster, where's the interlock?

    I say get the chimney and flue inspected. Get draft and smoke readings without the booster. I guess the service company is still using the wet kit? No printout of the combustion test?

  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Posts: 12,995

    This is not an approved use of this tape:

    image.png

    Obviously the smell is coming from inside the fire box where the flame is converting the liquid fuel into a very hot gas that is supposed to vent up the chimney. When everything is oerating properly, any smell would not be able to leak out of the joints that are marked with a green arrow. Therefore those joints do not need to be sealed because basement air would leak in to those joints combustion fumes can not leak out.

    Even if you believe that the fumes are leaking out of those joints, sealing them with that tape will not solve the odor problem because the blue arrow points to a much larger seam that will let much more exhaust odor into your basement. So that tape is useless in resolving your problem.

    To correct your problem you need to fix the source of the problem and not put bandaids on the problem in the home that you find the source of the odor leak. the blue arrow it the location of the odor leak and you can't seal that opening or the barometric damper will not be able to perform it job of regulating the ever changing draft opf that chimeny.

    Why is the chimney down drafting? Find that reason and you are on the way to correcting the odor problem.

    here is one video about down draft:

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?

  • Steve214
    Steve214 Posts: 18

    Get rid of the draft regulator and put a cap in its place. Riello burners when set up correctly have usually have low odors. I can’t stand tape on smoke pipe, it doesn’t do anything, causes the adhesive to stink and I rip it off. Maybe some insulation between the sections is missing?

  • EdTheHeaterMan
    EdTheHeaterMan Posts: 12,995

    I don't believe you have an easy fix. You have an architect who drew a bad design on a piece of paper, and it's too late to get any relief from that architect. He messed up, got paid for his poor design, and the previous owner lived with that mistake for years. Tough situation for you.

    image.png

    Edward Young Retired

    After you make that expensive repair and you still have the same problem, What will you check next?