Separate zones for radiant heat controlled by single T-stat: why weren't they just plumbed together?

Options
MoreCowbell
MoreCowbell Posts: 23
edited October 27 in THE MAIN WALL

I just purchased a house that uses a boiler for radiant heat in the floor. This house is configured with 10 zones, 10 zone valves, and 7 T-stats.

In my previous house also heated w/ radiant heat, there were 3 zones, 3 zone valves, and 3 T-stats - which seemed very logical.

In the new house, 3 pair of adjacent zones - each with its own zone valve - are controlled by 3 T-stats, respectively. I must wonder for each of these pairs, why wouldn't they have just been plumbed together to create a single zone and used a single zone valve? Put another way, what would be the mechanical advantage of having 2 adjacent zones controlled by a single T-stat?

Comments

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,005

    Good question… maybe someone had the idea of separating them once upon a time. Your guess is as good as mine.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
    GGross
  • I appreciate your response Jamie, though I was hoping to get something more definitive. I bet there HAS to be a rationale.

    My head scratch continues until someone smarter than me can please enlighten … 🤔

  • JUGHNE
    JUGHNE Posts: 11,658

    Could be a couple of reasons, maybe…..

    the flow together exceeds the capacity of one zone valve…..

    OR

    one zone is too small of a flow/load to prevent short cycling of the boiler.

    Just a WAG.

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,367

    You could eliminate 1 or 2 thermostats and wire two or three zone valves together to reduce the # of zones.

  • GGross
    GGross Posts: 2,109
    edited October 28

    in my house i had 5 thermostats and i think 9 zone valves. the thought was that if it was too uneven heating we could add a thermostat to the zones without their own thermostat. It's easier to wire in a new stat than to completely replumb zones in a finished house. what I ended up doing was eliminating 2 of those stats entirely, so i run it entirely on 3 stats now and the other valves actually just heat when any other stat calls. baseboard with outdoor reset and i don't use setbacks it works pretty much perfect for me.

    bjohnhy
  • For ED:

    I don't really mind the 7 T-stats - that would seem to offer better spatial resolution. What I think I'd prefer, though, is that there be 7 zones, such that the 3 pair that are individually controlled by each one's zone valve had each been physically "plumbed together" (i.e., merged) - not separated.

    Jughne raised an interesting theory that I hadn't thought of:

    "the flow together exceeds the capacity of one zone valve"

    I didn't really know that a zone valve has a particular "capacity". I'll have to ponder this. 🤔

  • GGross
    GGross Posts: 2,109

    Personally I view having more zone options as an upgrade. I would never consider re-piping my system to eliminate my unused zone valves. to each their own but for me I would view it as spending money to get rid of something that is essentially an "upgrade" that I am just not currently taking advantage of.

    bjohnhy
  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,005

    More zones is an upgrade, of course — as @GGross , said, much easier to put in the plumbing the first time around. In principle, that eventually breaks down to individual control of individual heating units.

    Wonderful. PROVIDED the system is also plumbed or controlled in such a way as to minimize or eliminate having the heat source — the boiler — cope with tiny zone A firing up, quitting, then tiny zone D firing up a minute later and so on. There are, of course, ways to do that — but it must be considered and accomplished.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
    GGross
  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,367

    @MoreCowbell

    Valves have a Cv rating.

    a valve with a rating of 1 Cv would mean when 1 gpm flows through the valve the pressure drop through the valve is 1psi.

    A typical zone valve usually have Cvs from around 3 to 8, it depends on the pipe size of the valve and how the valve is made. One mfgs 3/4" valve may not have the same Cv as a different MFGs valve of the same pipe size.

    Soa valve with a Cv of 8 would flow 8 gpm with a 1 psi drop etc

    You take a valve with a Cv of 8 and know at 8gpm the PD is 1 psi. Put what would the PD be if you only put a flow of 5 gpm through it?

    This can be calculated on a B & G "system sizer" wheel or you can download the electronic version.

    Anyhow I looked it up a valve with a Cv of 8 with 5gpm flow would have a pressure drop of .39psi

  • As I often have to do, I shall now answer my own queston. I can do this after having a recent discussion with a sharp hydronics guy who came to my home for an inspection. Thermodynamics considerations dictate that there is an optimal spatial area that can be efficiently served by a single zone. If this spatial area is exceeded, the hot water entering the zone heats the first part pretty well but by the end of the zone loop, the water has dissipated most of its heat. For this reason, for a "large" spatial area (I have 2 in my home), it's better to plumb the circuit into 2 tandem zones, each with its own Aquastat, and both controlled by a single T-stat. 🤔

    bjohnhyskyking1
  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,777

    A very unusual opinion!

    I have put radiant in 20,000 sq ft truck repair facialities as a single zone, single manifold, single thermostat.

    A proper radiant design tell you how many loops, what tube size, what length, how many gpm, what supply temperature and the designed delta T from loop beginning to loop end. Some designs tell you the pump spec for the design.

    News to me this optimal spatial area? What is the number he suggested? Obviously he thinks you area exceeds tha optimal number?

    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
    bjohnhyScottSecor
  • Too many variables.

    The temperature entering the slab, the gpm of each loop (when flowing by itself and when other zones are flowing) . the heat loss of the space, the length of line in each loop, the floor covering (and insulation value under the slab), the way the line was laid (serpentine or spiral), etc.

    In mine we did spiral , and 7 valves with 7 tstats (one loop per room). Do you have 10 rooms on the slab ?

    My shortest loop is about 80ft (bathroom), longest is 350 or 500 (? long ago.. it's the garage loop anyhow).

    I found the oil boiler was short cycling too much when the bathroom solo called, so I tied that room and the laundry room together at tstats so when the bathroom called, the laundry room would also heat.

    Are your 'tied' zones possibly the shorter loops of the house ?

    30+ yrs in telecom outside plant.
    Currently in building maintenance.
  • When I said "optimal spatial area", that was a simplified way of making the point that the area efficiently served by a zone takes into account water temperature at the start of the loop, flow rate, tubing ID, layout, etc. - all the things hot_rod and Dave mentioned. These are things that thermodydamics and engieering takes into account. In a simple sense, it comes down to size for effective heat transfer by the time the water exits the loop.

    What I was glad to have learned was that there was a logical reason for having - for some large heated areas - tandem loops.

    I appreciate all the thoughts expressed on this topic.

  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,777

    yes there are many variables to play around with. Increase the flow rates, shorten loops, tighter tube spacing are all variables that can be manipulated.

    In a few cases we put flow reversers on 1000’ loops, installed by mistake. the loop flowed one direction for 15 minutes, then the opposite

    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
  • skyking1
    skyking1 Posts: 166

    my thought was about the tubing length.

    In my install 200' was optimal so that is what I worked around.

    If I had a space that would be controlled by 1 stat but needed, lets say 500' of tubing it would be on three valves.