Condensate line with no drain (sub Arctic climate)

Options

Good day everyone, I live in Yellowknife Northwest Territories Canada where frankly speaking our winters are harsh. While extremely dry we get a lot of snowpack and frigid temps (totally normal to have cold spells that go from -30°C down to -50°C core temp) so how we heat our homes and the cost to do so is pretty important.

My home is older (late 80s manufactured home) that has been updated over the years and up until recently was heated by a biasi cast iron oil boiler. My setup is a bit unique in the fact that I have a detached heated garage (heated slab) where the boiler resides which then feeds a glycol send/return line underground in an insulated conduit up into my trailer to a fan coil that then distributes heat via forced air (floor ducts).

The problem Im facing is with my new boiler. I decided to upgrade this year because the cost of heating oil has over doubled in my region.. ($2.70 CAD a liter) and with my fuel consumption (3500 liters last year) staying on oil was cost prohibitive.

Long story short I hired a local outfit to take out the biasi unit and replace it with a high efficiency condensing boiler (Navein NHB-150H). The install went pretty smoothly all in all but one big issue that I'm concerned about going into the winter season is the condensate line.

I have no drainage in my garage whatsoever so what the installers did was adapt the 3/8 inch condensate to 3 inch PVC, (transition is inside the heated garage) which is then vented outside running parallel to the exterior wall, wrapped in heat trace and insulated, just dumping onto the gravel outside (doesn't break any codes here, very lax with that kinda stuff). I trusted them because they install these things for a living but it just isn't sitting right with me.

I have since installed a condensate pump to minimize more freeze-up but after more research I began to panic when I found out just how much condensate these boilers actually produce (about 0.82 gallons per gallon of propane). I'm not overly worried about the exhaust freezing as It is an extremely short run outside, with heat trace and the condensate pump, but what I am concerned is about the sheer amount of ice this line is going to shoot out over the winter.

What I came to find out after a good day of researching frantically at any way to realistically solve this issue (that doesn't cost a fortune) was that these condensing boilers produce significantly less condensate if the operating temperature on the return line is above 130-140°F because at that point the heat exchanger won't actually condense the vapor back into a liquid state.

I noticed that the installer set the target temp to 170°F and when running it often climbs to 180-185 and down to around 160 in standby. I know at those temps I'm loosing the efficiency gains you get from condensing the vapor back into liquid but it would appear that the amount of condensate it produces is significantly less.

I'm not sure if the installer did that intentionally since I didn't have a good place to dump the condensate indoors or it's just precaution for the potential heat loss the glycol lines run to the house but am I correct in believing that as it gets colder the boiler will run more frequently at a higher operating temp, where condensing doesn't occur majority of the time resulting in way less condensate to worry about? Even if it's 85% efficient this way I'm happy to pay a little extra in fuel for the peace of mind of not having to deal with the ice buildup.

The other option I was also considering was getting a rain barrel and submersible pump that I can then manually drain monthly instead which would completely eliminate freeze ups.

Sorry if this sounds a bit scatterbrained. Pluming is not my background at all. If my assumptions are correct over the heating season instead of having to worry about 1000+ gallons of condensate icing up outside my garage I'm more likely to have to deal with around 200 ish gallons which is far more manageable. Does this sound right?

Thanks in advance to any of you that have insight 🙏🏻

Comments

  • 109A_5
    109A_5 Posts: 4,798

    A byproduct of combustion is water vapor. So even if you are running the boiler at water temperatures that keep the boiler above condensing you still may have water draining out that you may have to deal with.

    image.png image.png

    Due to boiler design differences with an oil burner the water vapor just goes up the flue.

    With outdoor temperature like that I would be afraid the discharge from a condensate pump would eventually freeze up. The rain barrel may be a good idea at least to be prepared, depending on how readily available a submersible pump is, maybe wait a bit to purchase the submersible pump to see how things go.

    Since they are installing Navein boilers in your area maybe you can find someone that has a similar situation to yours and has lived with it for a few years and see how they deal with the condensate.

    National - U.S. Gas Boiler 45+ Years Old
    Steam 300 SQ. FT. - EDR 347
    One Pipe System
  • I know water vapor is a byproduct of combustion but I'm specifically worried about it being condensed back into a liquid (condensate line) over it just being expelled as a vapor with the flue gases. With my old oil unit i had peace of mind because it exhausted so hot out the chimney there was no issue.

    The exhaust of the flue gases, especially if the boiler is running at lower efficiency(non condensing) stays hot enough that icing typically isn't an issue in the north here. Sure sometimes the exhaust tips do form ice but never to the point of total blockage.

    I honestly doubt there are many people in town that are going to face my exact situation. Good majority of people here are still on oil and those that are on propane most likely have their furnace/boiler in their actual house where the condensate line can be tied into the drainage line.

    Unfortunately there is no way for me to add drainage to my garage without it costing a small fortune. Between bedrock and the permafrost line even doing an insulated run back to my home would be quite expensive too and still risks freezing.

    My only option is to have the condensate line dump outside the garage, but if I can reduce the amount of condensate the boiler produces (by up to 75-80%) by having the boiler run at a higher temp, forcing it to not condense most of the time, at the expense of some efficiency I see that as a fine trade off (less risk of freeze up and not dealing with a small ice rink worth of water lol)

    I read online that a lot of radiant heat systems when retrofitted with newer condensing boilers have to run high temps anyways due to how the radiators work which almost defeats the purpose when these boilers are being advertised to home owners as (high efficient).

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,012

    The tradeoff — as you have quite correctly deduced — is between the return water temperature (and hence condensing operation) and efficiency. The purported efficiency gain of the new boiers comes entirely from that condensation — so if you don't condense (run the t=return around 140 to 160 F) you lose that much efficiency (with gas, potentially around 10%). But… all the water vapour will go out the flue, and won't make a Titanic size iceberg on your yard. You still want the flue to pitch to drain outside — a small amount of water will appear, no matter what — but if you run warm enough you should be able to manage.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • Perfect thats exactly what I wanted to confirm. My flue is pitched and is fairly high up on the exterior wall so not too worried about it.

    In all honestly I'm fine with the lower efficiency as a trade off. Propane is a lot cheaper than oil where I am (I'm currently locked in at $0.87 per liter CAD) and based on my oil consumption from previous years I'm looking at probably spending between $4,000 to $4,500 CAD on propane which is still lower than what I was paying for oil even last year.

    I plan on monitoring the condensate line throughout the winter and if I do have icing problems I'll probably end up getting a rain barrel inside the boiler room as a reservoir and using a submersible pump to drain manually periodically. I'm in my garage almost every day which works well for that situation.

    Our territorial government offers rebates for wood/pellet stoves and I'm seriously considering getting one installed to supplement heat. Wanted to get through this winter first just on propane to see how she goes.

    Thanks for the reply Jamie!

  • JUGHNE
    JUGHNE Posts: 11,660

    I had this issue a few times. What worked was to take the discharge from the pump up high into 3/4" PVC inside the building. Then exit the building thru the wall at a 45 degree angle about 3' above the ground.

    The condensate comes out in a quick spurt. The height of the inside stand pipe adds some pressure to the discharge flow. You will get a inverted icicle below the discharge and may have to break it off occasionally. Same issue heat pumps have.

    IIRC, the top of the pipe was vented to air inside the building. Extending high above the tee inlet. You do not want the pump discharge to syphon and dribble out the pipe. You want the torpedo effect.

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,379

    I would use a condensate pump and do what @JUGHNE said. Heat trace and insulation can't hurt. You want to get the water through the pipe and outside as quickly as possible.

    See my crude drawing of what you might do. If the outside does freeze the condensate can dump into a barrel

    and the boiler will still run.