Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!
Scalding hot water
Hello forum, first post from a homeowner.
I have a 21 year old radiant heat system with 7 pumps that service heat, plus a primary pump that services the loop, and an injection pump that services the heating loop. There is also a pump for domestic hot water with water held in a 6 year old Weil McLain Series 2 water tank. There is also a separate pump for the basement baseboard. The pumps for the baseboard loop and the domestic hot water are connected to the boiler loop.
About a year ago I noticed heat coming from the baseboard when the primary pump was running to satisfy a call for heat in other zones and through trial and error concluded that the check valve or valves in the isolation valves were stuck open allowing water to run through that particular zone. Some vigorous manipulation of the isolation valves and gentle but firm taps with a hammer solved the problem.
Flash forward to two weeks ago when I noticed the domestic hot water was scaling hot and confirmed 180 degrees with my prob thermo. Just like before the primary pump was running and I could hear water running through the zone. Just like before a few taps with a hammer on the DHW isolation valves and some vigorous manipulation solved the the problem…until today and it's doing it again. Today however I didn't observe the primary pump running.
I'm noticing this happens earlier in the day when there hasn't been much of a call for hot water, and have read about "stacking." The temperature control is set for 110. I should point out that after correcting the check valve, the water was still 130 to 140 degrees.
Some recent repair history.
The water tank was replaced in 2020.
The expansion tank replaced in February 2026.
Both pressure relief valves for the boiler and hot water tank were replaced in July 2026.
The pressure reducing valve also replaced in July 2026.
I was very careful to not introduce air into the system and ran the loops so that air scrubbers could do their jobs.
I have 3 questions.
The first, should I flush out the boiler side of the domestic hot water tank to clear any sediment that might be gumming up the works? I know the water in the system is dirty but perhaps some street pressure might do the trick?
Second, is it possible that the water holding tank is being warmed through heat transfer from the hot water in the boiler loop? The inlet and outlet pipes are hot to the touch, I'd go as far as to say very hot, but I don't know the temp. Could that hot water transfer enough heat to the hot water tank, given enough time?
Third, should I replace the electric heating thermostatic control?
Thanks in advance!
Photos of the system:
Boiler loop in front, heating loop off to the right. The black (injection) pump serves the heating loop and the red pump serves the boiler loop. The baseboard pump I mentioned is to the left of the injection pump.
Return loop from hot water tank outlet at bottom of tank to the boiler loop.
Another view of the entire system with the DHW loop closest.
DHW pump feeding inlet side (middle) of hot water tank.
Pump
Check Trol isolation valve.
Comments
-
Any flow checks anywhere? I'm not familiar with those B&G circulators do they have flow checks in them?
You shouldn't need to flush anything out. It's a closed system and nothing should have got into it. If the installer left something in there it would have been a problem since day one. If anything I would check the flow check valves in the circulators if you have any.
-1 -
Can you get a better picture of the area from the Top of the domestic Hot Water storage tank? I dont see any anti-scald protection. VERY DANGEROUS if thats the case. Mad Dog
2 -
The Isolation valves have check valves built into them. There are no check valves in the pumps themselves.
0 -
Thanks Mad Dog. I'm virtually sure that there isn't any specific anti-scald protection except what might come built into the system. What would I be looking at if it existed?
0 -
-
Thanks. Yeah, don't have that. Will investigate.
In the meantime, I may have figured it out and now suspect its the thermostatic control.
I had the unit set to off and wife and I just took showers. Temp check post showers showed 165.
While taking the photos you asked for I decided to turn the thermostatic control back on and slowly adjusted the temp until the pump triggered…at 60 degrees.
Now I'm thinking I have or had two issues going on.
I've turned the thermostatic control down to 40 so see what happens, but at this point, swapping it out is an easy and cheap enough test.
0 -
Thanks. I'll keep an eye on it going forward to see if the problem replicates itself. Now I'm suspecting the thermostatic control.
I really appreciate the time you took to read and respond to my questions.
0 -
Your heating side issues are the secondary problem. I don't want to see anyone in your home get scalded. In general, the hottest water you should be seeing in a shower or bath is 120 degrees. Yes, you may indeed have a control issue, but an Anti-scald mixing valve is installed for just such a scenario. I wouldn't use the hot water in your home until you get a Professional to assess this and make it safe. Mad Dog
0 -
Agree with others, need a thermostatic mixing valve scald protection. ASSE 1017.
Your check valve is not working as designed.
The setpoint controls are not very accurate. If it's still higher than you'd like after fixing check valve, youll have to figure if this is due to your indirect pump running (call for heat) or if it's ghost flow. But I would be surprised if you have to turn set point down further.
To answer your questions.
- Flushing will not help with this problem
- Yes, ghost flow could be heating your help, due to non-functional check valve.
- TBD
0 -
Very much appreciated. This would have been something good to do when we built the house 21 years ago, but no reason to not do it next week, right? Thanks again for taking the time to read and comment.
0 -
Greening an Old Vapor System as we speak. Saw the word scalding, took a quick look and wanted to get my reply out. Back to work. Good luck. Mad Dog
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 87.9K THE MAIN WALL
- 3.3K A-C, Heat Pumps & Refrigeration
- 60 Biomass
- 430 Carbon Monoxide Awareness
- 136 Chimneys & Flues
- 2.2K Domestic Hot Water
- 6K Gas Heating
- 124 Geothermal
- 170 Indoor-Air Quality
- 3.9K Oil Heating
- 80 Pipe Deterioration
- 1.1K Plumbing
- 6.7K Radiant Heating
- 397 Solar
- 16.2K Strictly Steam
- 3.5K Thermostats and Controls
- 56 Water Quality
- 52 Industry Classes
- 51 Job Opportunities
- 18 Recall Announcements










