Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.

Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

Acoustic Camera To Diagnose Hellish Water hammer

Options

Hello,

I am a renter in a 1888 building with single pipe steam heat. We have an awful water hammer banging that happens each time the system turns on, and is extremely loud. Defiantly beyond any expected thermal expansion and venting with steam, I have lived in steam heated buildings for the bast 5yr+ and am familiar with the normal sounds.

In my frustration, I purchased a acoustic camera (fotric td2e) to attempt to determine the source of the sound.

It appears to NOT be our radiator, but instead coming from the pipes running up to other units in our building, Previously, the ceiling above this area was opened up in an attempt to solve the issue, and I believe some pipe pitching angles up there were changed, but with zero effect on the hammering.

It appears that the source of the sounds is this small (6in or so) horizontal section with two elbow on the long vertical going up to another unit. My questions:

• How likely is it that this tiny 90deg bend could be causing the issue? I know the small section has insulation removed, and so it could APPEAR that it is the source of the sound simply because sound is traveling through the pipe and is loudest where un-insualted

• what other diagnostics could I do to help find the source of this error, I am armed with this acoustic camera and willing to learn! Hoping to be able to send info to the Landlord and get this solved so we can sleep again!

Photo on 2026-10-28 at 5.37 AM.jpg Photo on 2026-10-28 at 5.38 AM #3.jpg Photo on 2026-10-28 at 5.38 AM #2.jpg

Comments

  • More:

    • I realize copper is not the right material for steam. I know our radiators in our unit are all one pipe, so it is my assumption that these two pipes that run through are also one pipe lines to other units in the building, as you can see though one is copper which is strange,

    • The system produces a rhythmic water hammer, loud clank every 5sec or so while the system is turning on. Am I barking up the wrong tree? Should this be a system flush or bleed and not likely a physical issue?

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,029

    I honestly doubt that that short section of pipe is long enough to be the source of a water hammer problem. To create a water hammer, you need to have a long enough section ofo pipe to actually accumulate significant condensate — and, perhaps more to the point, allow a wave of it to gain some speed. That section is, I think too short on either count.

    There may be a longer poorly pitched section.

    However, be very sure that you are really hearing water hammer and not expansion. Granted, expansion noises are rarely as loud as a really healthy water hammer, but they can be loud — and they tend to be repetitive, which you comment suggests this one may be. They also only happen only when a pipe is warming up.

    And they are much worse with copper!

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
    zevhoover
  • zevhoover
    zevhoover Posts: 5
    edited October 28
  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,029

    A bit hard to tell — but I'm inclined to expansion, rather than water hammer. The real tell is that fast double hit at 0:16 and again at 0:37. Water hammer rarely repeats that fast; expansion does.

    So then the question is… where is the pipe rubbing and anchored so that it sticks and slips as it expands, and what — if anything — can be done. Ideally the pipe will be fixed at one location — usually an elbow or a T — and able to expand freely for the entire rest of its length. If it's rubbing on something along that length, maybe you can locate that and address it.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
    zevhoover
  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,400

    Maybe try a mechanics stethescope and use a level to check the pitch on all pipes. You have to put your detective hat on to find this.

    Just remember, "every drop of water (and water is condensed steam) that is in a pipe has to be able to drain back to the boiler"

    If it sits in the pipe it can cause hammer.

    Now I admit "every drop of water" is a bit of an exaggeration but you get the picture.

    zevhooverMad Dog_2
  • How would you advise using the stethoscope? Just to localize by where it's loudest to try and find the source, or to actually tell more about the sound and what it may be.

    Being an apartment unfortunately my sleuthing abilities are limited to my unit.

    Here is the pipes as the go up into the ceiling from a previous attempt to fix where a plumber came and apparently corrected the pitch as well as adding insulation to deaden the sound. This had no effect.

    5-May 08, 2026 14-25-44-ghRE.jpg 4-May 08, 2026 14-25-38-kvYA.jpg 3-May 08, 2026 13-25-56-W1Bg.jpg
  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,478

    anywhere the pipe goes through the ceiling or floor there should be a gap around it. if the ceiling or floor is tight against the pipe, especially the copper pipe, you're going to get expansion noise. you can put soft foam in the gap, but don't fill it with wood or plaster or hardening foam. If the copper is reasing directly on the structure here it could cause noise too:

    image.png
  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,400

    Its probably going to bang the loudest where the water is. Usually we just snoop around with a level and our eye balls and can tell where the pipe is off pitch or sagging.

    Steam pipes should pitch 1/4"/foot minimum in the direction the condensate has to go. Don't forget in some areas of a 1 pipe system the water flows against the steam in the branches and run outs. In the mains it usually flows with the steam (but not always)

  • Thank you all for your insightful comments.

    I am highly convinced the issue is right in this area, potentially right below or above the floor/cieling though. If I grab the pipe and yank it up and down, it makes an almost identical sound. it could be the copper pipe expanding at a different rate then the steel pipe it is tied to next to it… more investigation. Thanks for your input!

  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,478

    if it makes the sound when you grab the pipe and move it, it is definitely lack of clearance for the pipe to be able to move.

  • Grallert
    Grallert Posts: 1,255

    Miss Hall's School service mechanic, greenhouse teacher, dog walker and designated driver