Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.

Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

Fresh air intake

Options

I've been asked to help a local non-profit ( a peer -mentoring mental health organization) get ready for winter by surveying their several (7 in one 2-story ~50'x20' building !!) furnaces and replace filters as required. I've done a fair amount of minor work for them, so it's not my first time in the building. The building has been re-muddled many times…there are 3 different ceilings in some places, each layer lower than the one above and the in-between spaces filled with live, dead and somewhere in between "stuff".

Two of the units, both ceiling hung, one above the drop ceiling, one exposed, included short duct runs** from outdoors directly into the return air trunks. These were NOT part of a modern HRV system, and there were no dampers in the outdoor intakes. Thankfully, one of these systems was removed as part of a recent remodel. The remaining one —-it's actually not a furnace but is an air handler for a roof mounted heat pump, part of an SDHV HVAC system—-is mounted above a drop ceiling, no drop down access door and a very tight fit to the grid, and popping panels sucks (sucks as in, the fit is so tight that somewhere in the past someone substituted acrylic diffuser panels because you can flex those out). On this unit, the short outside air intake is flex-ducted from the thru-wall exterior grill to the air handler return plenum, just ahead of the filter rack. But, the flex duct has no slack, and absolutely prevents getting a correctly sized, unbent filter into the filter rack. The building owners (the org. owns the building) have had a few different HVAC service co.s over the years I've known them, and let's just say the techs haven't been the A-team….I've seen bent filters, doubled filters, cut filters…

Which brings me to why I'm posting….Given that these fresh air intakes are NOT combustion air, and NOT part of a modern HRV system —this is NOT an airtight building—is there any reason I shouldn't just remove the fresh air intake? Was it code at some point? An early attempt at air quality management? I'd like to be able to actually get the right filter installed..right now there's a 14x25 kitty-cornered into the 16x25 (I think) rack because that's all the last guy up there could get in.

** I've been told that not long after the exposed ceiling hung unit was installed in an attempt to get heat to that section of the building, the fresh air duct run was also a squirrel run…guess the installer didn't have an intake with a grill on the truck that day…

Comments

  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,031

    May have been an attempt at improving indoor air quality — which was, very likely, none too good. There was also, for a while there, a line of thinking (along with open windows and so on) that you could prevent disease — particularly influenza — with fresh air.

    My inclination would be to block them off — provided that there is enough air exchange in the building from other sources. Like… draughts. Now of course if someone has decided to eliminate the draughts in the name of energy efficiency, you may be in a no-win situation. Not enough air exchange without them, but poor control with them.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
  • Kaos
    Kaos Posts: 1,010

    People often forget that the "V" in HVAC stands for ventilation. This type of passive fresh air supply is not ideal but better than hoping for correct air from the leaks in the structure. Those change with weather/wind, at least this provides a fixed amount of fresh air supply.

    bburd
  • Jamie Hall
    Jamie Hall Posts: 28,031

    Just as an historical note of caution — during the mid-1970s there was a huge push for improving buiding heating efficiency. The number of quack ideas which were tried was really amazing — but one of the worst was sealing up buildings which had depended on more or less controlled natural ventilation for indoor air quality management. This happened in commercial buildings, schools, office buildings, and barns particularly — and while the results were rarely actually catastrophic (although there were some flat out catastrophes from moisture accumulation) the overall effect was… lamentable.

    We still see lingering aspects of this, of course, and it is a wise building designer or, more often, heating organisation, who remembers to provide adequate air exchange in a building — partcularly in renovations and "upgrades" to existing structures.

    Br. Jamie, osb
    Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England