Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
If you've found help here, check back in to let us know how everything worked out.
It's a great way to thank those who helped you.
Proper boiler sizing and equipment
I have been reading through many of the threads here to try to form an opinion on a new system as a homeowner, and I need some help. In short, I have a 30+ year old oil boiler with indirect hot water that I want to replace. The house, located in Rhode Island, has about 3,500 sq/ft on the first two floors with about 500 sq/ft finished in the basement. It currently has an Axeman-Anderson that's labeled at 200k BTU, with 6 zones plus one for HW. I have talked to three contractors about a new system, and here's what I am getting:
1) An independent contractor - replace with a Pensotti DK2-8 (222k BTU DOE) - this contractor visited the house and measured the baseboards on one floor
2) Service company my oil delivery company recommends - replace with a Biasi B10-7 (193k BTU) and a HeatFlo HF-40 indirect
3) Largest company came and is doing a heat loss calc, but I think will cost 30% more than option 2 - Recommending Viessmann V-100 series
I did a quick heat loss calculation and I am coming up with just under 100k BTU. This seems low to me, but I understand that it is normal for it to be much lower than what was originally placed in houses decades ago.
I like the idea of a triple pass boiler, and potentially a ODR. My goal is greater efficiency, a reliable system, and a good servicing company.
1) Based on my general sizing stats, am I right that a 200k BTU boiler is way oversized? Is it possible that it actually would be better sized with something in the 100k range?
2) Any equipment recommendations? From this site, I see a lot about Viessmann controls being expensive, but they're good. I don't see much about Pensotti or Biasi. Is there an indirect tank that will last longer than others?
Any help or guidance you can provide is appreciated. Thanks!