Thermostat question

JohnW2

We've lived in a house with a one pipe steam system for 10 years. We previously had one of the old round Honeywell mercury thermostats, and our system ran very well. It did a great job of keeping nice even heat in the radiators. Recently, the system started to go haywire. It would cycle on every five minutes, run for a minute, and then shut off. The guy who looked at it said that the heat anticipator in the thermostat was shot. He thought that a new gas valve we put on at the end of last year had caused the problem because it was 24v. However, I still have the old gas valve that we took off, and it was also 24v., so I don't think that was what caused it. Anyway, he installed a digital nonprogrammable thermostat that has no setting or adjustment for steam. It kicks on when it is one degree below the set point and shuts off when it is one degree above it. The problem is that it takes approximately 45 minutes for it to raise the house two full degrees, but by then the radiators are so hot that the temperature will rise an additional two degrees above the setpoint. So now the system will not kick on again until the house drops four degrees, which takes a couple of hours. So we're getting long cycles once every several hours, and the radiators are always going from too hot to too cold instead of maintaining even heat. We're also getting annoying banging sounds from the radiators that we never had before; we used to have very quiet radiators with our old thermostat. I suspect that the problem is from the expansion and contraction caused by going from too cold to too hot. Is it possible to still get thermostats with heat anticipators? I'm gong to go crazy if I have to live with the system this way. Thanks for any suggestions.

Si_zim

Anticipation

Hi

I believe most modern digital thermostats which include features named like "smart response" have logic which learns the reactiveness of your system and try to plan for that... which is better than a simple anticipator in theory.

Otherwise I think Honeywell's newer (post-Hg) Round tstats like T87 still have anticipators.

Jamie Hall

By far the simplest thing to do

is to get a replacement Honeywell T87N round.  It doesn't actually have an anticipator; rather, it has a setting for 1 cycle per hour which is usually correct for steam.



Cheap.  Reasonably accurate.  Reliable.  Amazon has them, if your local big box doesn't.

JohnW2

CPH

Thanks. When you have a CPH thermostat, does it force it to run the number of cycles that you set if for or is that just a maximum number? For instance, last night mine cycled on once every three hours and I had the freeze/burn issue. Would one of these thermostats force it to run exactly once per hour?

Mark N

Thermostat

What thermostat was installed on your system? Did you check the installation manual to make sure it is set up correctly? The CPH setting on a Honeywell replaces the anticipator. If is set to 1 it won't force the boiler to run once an hour. It will run when when the room temp drops to set point minus the differential and then turn off so as not to over shoot the set point.

JohnW2

Robertshaw RS 2110

The Thermostat is a Robertshaw RS 2110. He left the box here, and I couldn't find anything on the box or online that says that this thermostat should be used with a steam system. In terms of setting it up, there's really not much to do. It's working the way he said it would: it kicks on at one degree below the set point and off at one degree over. So if I set it for 67, it kicks on at 66 and off at 68, but then the radiators are so hot that it will get up to 70 or 71. Then it has to drop four or five degrees before it will kick on again, and at that point the pipes are cold again. Thus the burn/freeze cycle. There's nothing on it that you can set so that it will shut off before it reaches the set point. Thanks for your response to my CPH question. I guess I'm confused as to what the term means. Does setting it at one CPH mean that that it will run no more than one cycle per hour?

Mark N

Diff setting

According to the manual for that thermostat on pexsupply.com the factory default setting on that thermostat is 2. You could try adjusting it to 1 and see how it works out. Push the up and down arrows for 3 seconds. Diff should be displayed use the up and down arrows to adjust.

JohnW2

It's at 1

Thanks, I checked and it's already set for 1. I feel like I need something that's adjustable to .5.

Si_zim

Maybe get a replacement

Maybe try to get a simple Honeywell 6350 from a big box retailer (or Amazon for just over 40bucks - but delivery will probably get snarled by Hercules).

For that price it should be worth it to sort out your issue - and if it doesnt do what you need you can return it

nicholas bonham-carter

The first thing to do:

Short out the thermostat wires to imitate a constant call for heat, and then see if the short-cycling disappears.

If it does, then of course the problem is in the thermostat. If not, then check the venting, and pressuretrol.--NBC