30% efficiency gain on Burnham 206 gas boiler

Options
jesmed1
jesmed1 Posts: 1,630
edited October 23 in Gas Heating

A quick update on a previous thread about my sister's Burnham 206 atmospheric gas boiler. She bought the house last summer in the Boston suburbs and got slammed with a $6k+ gas bill for 3300 sq ft last winter. I visited periodically through the winter and noticed the boiler room was always hot and the boiler water temp was always 170-180. And it looked to me like the boiler was short-cycling. I suspected the boiler was running inefficienctly, but we didn't know how bad it was until this summer when the gas company sent her a letter saying they had mistakenly billed her for the wrong meter, and instead of a $3k gas bill, her actual bill was over $6k. Fortunately because it was their error, they didn't make her pay the extra $3k.

When I heard how much gas she had used, I ran some house heat loss numbers and felt certain the heat loss should not be bad enough to fully account for the high gas usage. I then did a survey of the heating system and found numerous problems: too many zones, thermostats with differentials set too low, no automatic vent damper, and boiler short-cycling, typically bouncing off the aquastat high limit of 180 F.

With help from the good HH'ers here, I did the following:

  1. Changed thermostat settings to maximize differential/swing.
  2. Disconnected some thermostats and jumpered several contiguous zones together on the Taco 6-zone controller so those circs ran off one thermostat.
  3. Installed a new auto vent damper to replace the one that had originally come with the boiler but then was removed at some point.
  4. Installed a new Tekmar 256 reset controller at the suggestion of @Steamhead . I have it set for a minimum water temp of 140 and a max of 160 at outdoor design temp. Those are "first cut" settings that can be adjusted later if needed.

Now in the first month of the heating season here in New England, I have some preliminary results.

Last year's heating season total average usage was 0.40 therms/HDD65 (after subtracting for DHW).

Last year's October billing period usage was also 0.40 therms/HDD65. So that number appears to have been stable across a range of temperatures throughout the winter.

This year's October billing period usage (for the first 3 weeks in October) was 0.27 therms/HDD.

That is a 30%+ reduction in therms/HDD65 (after correcting all usage for DHW).

With the Tekmar 256 running ODR, the boiler stops firing noticeably sooner while the circulators continue running. I'm further encouraged by the fact that I didn't install the Tekmar until 1 week into this 3-week test period. (The actual bill from the gas company will come next week, but I read the meter myself today and did the math for the 3 weeks ending today). So future billing periods in which the Tekmar is running the entire time should be slightly better.

I will continue to monitor future billing periods but am optimistic/hopeful that the 30%+ reduction in therms/HDD65 will continue through the winter.

Thanks to everyone who made suggestions, especially @Steamhead for the Tekmar 256, which is working great.

Hot_water_fanSteamNow

Comments

  • Steamhead
    Steamhead Posts: 19,023

    Thanks for the update, @jesmed1 . Glad to help.

    Co-Founder, All Steamed Up, Inc.

    Semi-retired

    Baltimore, MD, USA

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,379
    edited October 23

    I wonder if it will cycle at 160 when it gets really cold. If it is over radiated maybe not. 30% is crazy good.

  • jesmed1
    jesmed1 Posts: 1,630
    edited October 23

    I think the right perspective is the boiler was set up crazy bad to start with: vent damper had been removed, too many zones, micro zones, Tstat swing settings too low, etc, etc. It just shows how inefficient you can make a cast iron boiler with a bad setup. @hot_rod often shows that Brookhaven Labs cycle efficiency graph that drops off steeply. Maybe we were at 45% cycle efficiency before and have now gotten up to around 60%.

    I didn't get around to finishing the radiation calcs, so I'm just guessing on the reset curve. The most efficient strategy is to set the curve deliberately too low, then wait for the outside air temps to drop low enough that the system can't keep up, and adjust incrementally. With the max target temp now set at 160, with the Tekmar's differential added in, the actual max temp will be around 170, then dropping to 150 or so before the boiler fires again. It might be December or January before the radiation can't keep up at that temp, if at all. Now that I know the Tekmar is working right, I'm tempted to drop the reset curve further and see how low I can go before the radiation can't keep up. The deeper I can get into the season with the 140 minimum, the better.

  • GroundUp
    GroundUp Posts: 2,573

    I have an old HE-5 that was sucking down 1400-1700 gallons of LP annually in a 2800SF 5 unit apartment building I bought a few years ago. Literally the only things I did were turn the water temp from 180 to 160 and add a Ranco inline as a WWSD of sorts set to 70*. Last winter it used approximately 900 gallons, though one of the units was empty for a couple months so it was only set to 50*. For being a 35 year old dinosaur boiler that's way too big with 4 micro zones, I thought that was a pretty big step in the right direction. I bought a scratch & dent CGi-4 this spring for a song to replace the HE-5 with, but never got around to installing it yet so I may have another year to compare. I hope your sister appreciates your expertise!

    jesmed1
  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,379
    edited October 23

    @jesmed1 If the radiation can't heat the building with the water temp your using will not the Tekmar just keep cycling the boiler on and off without reaching temp contributing to short cycling? I agree the lower the water temp the less fuel you use. Just wondering if it is a case of diminishing returns. Either way you have saved (or will save) a bunch of fuel.

  • jesmed1
    jesmed1 Posts: 1,630
    edited October 23

    @GroundUp That is impressive improvement, also in the 30%-ish range.

    @EBEBRATT-Ed That's a good question. I will be curious to see how the efficiency changes as the weather gets colder and the target temperature increases. The short-cycling thing sounds paradoxical, as yes, in reality the Tekmar is now making the boiler fire for shorter periods of time, with a larger number of firing cycles, than it was before. But I guess the lower water temperature more than compensates. I think you're right that there will be some diminishing returns as the water gets hotter.

  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,799

    This has come up before on HH, with ODR on an oversized boiler. Which increases cycling, as Ed mentioned.

    If that appears to be the case that run cycle % calculation will tell the efficiency story.

    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
  • fentonc
    fentonc Posts: 343

    I've done a lot of experimenting with my wildly oversized / short-cycling boiler. The strategy I've settled on is to just run it with a very big differential (60F in my case), which gives much longer burn cycles and winds up providing some 'natural' zone synchronization because the calls for heat take longer and overlap more. I built a little custom controller that uses a strap-on temp sensor and sits between the zone valves and the thermostats, and has an extra relay to inhibit the burner. It's set to operate between 180F and 120F (my gas pressure is a little low, leading to higher excess air and and a lower flue gas condensation point, but 130F would work fine too). When all the calls for heat are satisfied, it opens the non-bedroom zone valves and dumps the until it's down to about 80F. If the radiation/boiler isn't so oversized, you could modulate the lower limit up based on how long the calls for heat take (but mine heats the house fine on the coldest days with it pegged at the 120F minimum).

    From what I can measure, it seems to have raised the system efficiency (in terms of BTUs delivered into the radiators vs BTUs burned) from the low 50%s into the low 70%s.

    jesmed1
  • jesmed1
    jesmed1 Posts: 1,630
    edited October 28

    @fentonc That's a nice improvement. For an apples-to-apples comparison on fuel consumption, we can take your efficiency numbers and turn them into fuel consumption numbers. For example, if your house heat loss was, say, 10,000 BTU/hr, at 50% efficiency you would have been burning 20,000 BTU/hr to keep up. Then later at 70% efficiency you would have been burning 14,300 BTU/hr to keep up. So your new-vs-old fuel consumption ratio would have been 14,300/20,000 = 0.71, for about a 30% reduction, right about the same reduction I got.

    One interesting question your strategy brings up is whether it's better to (a) keep maximum water temp as low as possible (with outdoor reset, for example) or (b) minimize the total number of cycles by making the boiler runs as long as possible even though you end up with hotter water at the end of the burn. I took approach (a) and you took approach (b), but it seems like we both ended up with about the same results in terms of % fuel savings.

  • fentonc
    fentonc Posts: 343

    There are so many effects at play that it's surprisingly hard to translate between 'efficiency' and gas consumption. I can absolutely say that my system goes through way fewer burn and heating cycles due to the large differential, and the thermal purge system means more heat gets emitted through the radiators, but it also raises the average temperature slightly, which will increase heat loss. I think it's a nice net benefit for comfort (and less thermal expansion pipe noise, as the pipes now cool down to room temp less often). I also made changes like installing a heat pump water heater next to the boiler, which is just leaching heat from the boiler one way or another (and the load goes up throughout the season as the incoming water temp drops).

    I think lowering the max water temp with a smaller (say 20F) differential vs higher temp but larger differential is actually the exact same effect in terms of lowering average water temperature, and providing some natural synchronization between zones by taking longer to satisfy calls for heat. Re: 'hotter water at the end of the burn' - this was exactly why I implemented the thermal purge system, as the connected radiation is pretty large compared to the residual heat left in the boiler, so it can pretty rapidly dump it. If you don't have a purge system, just because the rate that BTUs are emitted drops off as the water temperature drops, the time spent in a given heating cycle will be weighted towards the lower range of water temperatures from your aquastat. If you run your boiler between 160F-140F, it will, on average, be more likely to be between 140-150 than 150-160 when the call for heat is satisfied. If you run it between 180F-120F you will also, on average, spend a lot more time from 120-130 than from 180-170.

    My take away from all of these experiments is that there's a lot of ways to go from 'terrible' to 'mostly fine', and improving on 'mostly fine' is very difficult just because there is so much noise in any measurements you can reasonably do.

    jesmed1