Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.
Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

Working on Junk

Options
There was one of a small sign hanging at my late father's desk quoting, " Only the riches can afford a poor heating system"

Comments

  • Bill Nye_2
    Bill Nye_2 Member Posts: 538
    Wasted time

    It is a shame that we have to spend so much time working on junk equipment. I guess it pays the bills. Junk equipment takes so much more energy, mental, physical, and natural resources.

    It is so depressing to have to service equipment that was installed by someone who didn't care or didn't know. The pipes that surround the boiler are like prison bars keeping you away from gaining access to do a complete and thorough service .

    You can defend old equipment all you want but there comes a time............... In the oil crunch of the late 70's a lot of 1725 burners got swapped out for 3450 stuff. How about now? Is $2+ or $3 a gallon fuel going to be enough incentive for the public to upgrade.

    My boss made a wise statement today. We were discussing an upgrade of outdated equipment. The customer didn't want to hear it. My boss said " I'm not here to make friends with the customer" It is like when you go to the doctor and he tells you what is wrong after an examination. It is no different than when we examine the boiler, just facts. We are not after the customers money or trying to drum up work. Just stating facts and they still don't want to hear it.

    The public needs education on heating equipment. It has such an impact on comfort and well being and the pocket book. I am amazed at how little people seem to care.

    What a joy it is to service equipment that has been well maintained and installed by a professional. Well, not a joy but it is much more pleasant.

    When I have to service a POS like we did this morning I wish I had the power of the boiler police. I would make that guy repipe it so it could be serviced, fix all the leaks, replace the 26 yr old burner and put some lights in the basement.

    This guy wasn't broke either. Swimming pool, lots of land, toys.......... won't spend a dime on heating equipment. A new boiler would pay for it self twice in saings

    Please excuse me, this was just my Friday night rant, had to get it off my chest. I am such an idealist
  • Ragu_4
    Ragu_4 Member Posts: 44
    I hear you Bill

    That stuff can be depressing. I get the feeling that there have always been hacks out there when I look at one of those Frankenstein piping arrangements. Yikes!!

    You are right on the money about educating customers re: wasted fuel dollars with old junk. What to do? I keep having the nagging thought that Steve Ebels was correct: $4.00 oil brings a rude awakening.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • Keith_8
    Keith_8 Member Posts: 399
    JUST ONE MORE YEAR

    I'm trying to get one more year out of my boiler. We will swap it out next summer. Next summer comes and goes and it's still chugging along. Inefficient and unrealiable but it's still throwing heat in the house. How many times have we heard that?

    I'm not in the residential side any longer and I know people make their financial decisions diffently than business people do but I have to believe that most home owners must be waking up by now, no?

    If not then either we stink at marketing or they refuse to hear the message. Which is it?

    Keith

  • don_182
    don_182 Member Posts: 69
    I know

    from experience as long as you are willin to keep fixing it they will never replace it.

    So why are you still fixing it?

    I'm still waiting on that day where I can say sorry, we only service what we install.


  • Where I work, if you refuse to work on a piece of equipment or condemn it, the service manager will only send someone else out to work on it. If they refuse, he'll someone else. He's a sneaky guy. He dosen't let the other guys know that it's already been condemned. Why? Because he's afraid to talk to the customer and tell them that they have to actually spend money on new stuff.
    I work for an oil company and they're stuck back in the 1960's.
  • Al Corelli
    Al Corelli Member Posts: 454
    That $4 Statement is False.

    Oil may go to 10 bucks a gallon, and people will never wake up. There is no "magic" ceiling.

    When oil hit 70 cents was when people should have woken up.

    I believe it is more of people living at the upper end of their means. When it comes to "fixing what ain't broke" the money is hard to come by. But new cars, and other tangible "instant-enjoyments", can be immediately felt and seen (and shown off).

    We need MTV to a "bling-bling" series on celebrity's houses. All the acoutrements displayed on TV to modern music, half nekkid wimmens.....sorry. You get the idea. Who the heck would ever think the whole (younger) world would be wearing their pants hanging off their butts with 10lbs of fake gold around their necks, and have $500 cars with $15,000.00 worth of wheels on it? And a super-expensive stereo that was too loud to listen to?

    Boys, we gots to add some bling to the basement...

    We are the only people (Wallies, and some of our customers) who show off their heating equipment and mechanical rooms.

    I'm off to the Jersey Shore.
  • Leo
    Leo Member Posts: 772
    Hey Mike

    It sounds like your work for my FORMER boss.

    Leo
  • tom_49
    tom_49 Member Posts: 267
    marketing

    Keith,

    Great point about the marketing. This industry does VERY little marketing. Oh yeah, all the manufactures advertise in the trade mags. trying to get us to install their stuff, but how many advertise to the general public, not many. The car makers dont advertise to mechanics do they? They have an entire section in the paper for sales. When was the last boiler or furnace add you saw in any paper?

    Its time for the manufactures to step up and promote their wares to then non-trades types. Then maybe John Q. Public will listen. And it will make our sales calls easier.Because right now are marketing does stink.

    Just a thought.

    Now Im going fishing on my boat I found advertised in a fishing magazine.

    Tom
  • Josh_10
    Josh_10 Member Posts: 786


    True auto makers do advertise to the general market but I have yet to see one talk about gas milage as a major selling point. I saw a Honda commercial for a Civic. There was no mention of the Hybrid Civic nor was there any mention that the regular Civic gets almost 40MPG. It is always about the syling or speed. It is the informed that buy Hybrids just like it is the informed that buy efficient heating systems.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • joel_19
    joel_19 Member Posts: 933
    marketing

    Yes our industry has horrible marketing and always has. the companies advertise to us not to the customer. Mitsubishi has recently been advertising to the customer and our phones lit up with folks wanting quotes on them . Why boiler or control companies don't do this is a mystery.

    When the companies do advertise to the consumer they also tend to screw it up , they should ask for dealer input. Take York they spent millions pushing the Affinity line to consumers , but unfortunately marketing never talked to engineering or production. Consequently folks where calling up trying to buy units that we couldn't even sell them.

    Then they adverstised them again in the middle of the freakin summer . More folks called only to be upset again as most of us good HVAC guys where already booked for the summer.
    Conclusion York basically wasted millions of dollars . I think they hire these harvard educated wizz kids with marketing degrees , problem is they've never even run a lemonade stand.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • Keith_8
    Keith_8 Member Posts: 399
    Why

    Do you think the manufactorurs are concerned that we might think they are trying to go around us and deal with the public directly? Or is that the margins are so tight on equipment that they can't afford it?

    Seems like they would have the best of both worlds if they promoted their product and our expertise.

    How would you guy's like the consumer steering the equipment choices instead of us? The drug companies have done this by marketing to the consumer instead of the doctors. Seems like the drug companies have increased sales every year.

    Keith
  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Member Posts: 19,625


    I think Al Corelli has this right. Spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on a new heating system dosen't "feel good" It means nothing to most (but not all) homeowners. They would rather spend it on vacations, new cars, boats etc. Well who wouldn't. Only the people in the heating, cooling or plumbing businesses know the value of a new heating system. Maybe someone who has lived with a "no heat" situtation may understand.

    Unfortunatly most see it as a money stealer. Heating fuel along with its nasty equipment. Something that is taking their hard earned money that they could be spending on other things to have fun with.

    And the jokes about "plumbers crack" etc. most have little or no respect for someone in the business who gets his hands dirty.

    Ed
  • joel_19
    joel_19 Member Posts: 933
    the glass

    while many folks feel that way about thier heating equipment not all do. the way to sell it is to show them that if they get the good equipment and quality instal that they will then have more money for all the good stuff. We just did a boiler replacement job where i think they will save several hundred$ a month . Not too mention a quieter system , better looking , lower electrical consumption you know the drill. I talked about the technical stuff his eye's glazed over.

    Guy was a car nut i told him with with the new boiler i was throwing in the lease on a new sports car. His eyes lit right up "huh?" .

    "Well sir we are going to save you enough each month to cover the lease on a new sports car."

    More boiler really does equall more bling and not just in the boiler room.

    "When can you start"

    The glass is not half empty folks it is half full and i like to think mines full of of very fine wine. It's all in how you look at it boys.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • clammy
    clammy Member Posts: 3,242
    feel the pain

    Mr.Nye i feel your pain i also like yourself see it all to much .The can't fix junk statement is one i had even heard from my dad when i was a youngster amd as for working on old no maintance boiler who's owners have all the bling bling and a new 30 grand paver drive way but always complain about the oil compusumtion is like a comdey show .Where i work and live could possible be the worst here it's all about out doing the jones in all that can be seen and since your heating system is not seen it does not fall into that catagory of it matters .One small story about a large gravity system i looked at for a possible replacement the HO said she need 2 350 btu boiler and she had alreadt talked to 3 or 4 plumbers so before talking my buddy said lets see what she has as i usually like to get a feel for the HO so i listened to him after checking out her 1910 byrant boiler no plates or anything and poking around the home she said a bunch of toes heater did not work and some other promble4ms i asked if a heat lose had been done and she said they all counted rads ,i stated that in our price we would do a heat lose to properly size her boiler she stated that she was shopping for the best price we both stopped talking and staed we wpould not be the low bidder and said good bye the funny part is the home was about 12,000 to 15,000 sq.feet with yearly taxes that are probaly more then a good 2 stage heating system with out door reset ,she will get what she paid for garbage .It seems every one wants the best but they want to pay peanuts for it Peace and good luck clammy

    R.A. Calmbacher L.L.C. HVAC
    NJ Master HVAC Lic.
    Mahwah, NJ
    Specializing in steam and hydronic heating

  • Maine Doug_46
    Maine Doug_46 Member Posts: 1
    Advertising

    An area P&H company is doing cable TV ads featuring Biasi boilers. They show the triple pass and mention efficiency and oil savings etc.
  • S Ebels
    S Ebels Member Posts: 2,322
    And how many companies are still like that!!??

    IMHO if there is only one single heating company in our whole industry that is still refusing to embrace new heating technology, it's one to many. Same goes for consumers/customers/clients.

    I really wonder what is wrong with companies and technicians that hang on to methods and materials that were developed in the 40's and 50's. Around here I see it in HWH and FHA systems alike. Antiquated piping practices, obsolete duct systems being re-used instead of ripped out, no system control except a T-87, zoning is nearly 100% absent in FHA systems and poorly done in a lot of HWH that I see. I'm talking about new and/or new replacement installs.

    To me, businesses and techs that do it because they've always done it that way are the biggest problem our industry faces. Even bigger than a lack of technicians who are actually worthy of the title.


    A cast iron boiler, operating with OD or ID reset or a 90% FA furnace is the MINIMUM that should ever be installed or sold. So much has changed in the control area and in modulating firing rates that the single stage condensing appliances, be they boilers or furnaces, should be considered base grade stuff. Then add ground source heat, solar and even high efficiency air to air heat pumps.......how many companies deal with those systems, understand them or even know about them.

    We're never going to go anywhere as long as 80% of the trade is stuck in the dark ages.

  • Leo
    Leo Member Posts: 772
    A lot are

    I work in a small town with three small oil companies and two plumbing companies and one propane company. One of the oil companies tells customers they will not work on Riello Burners or System 2000's. The propane company had something going and asked to borrow a combustion test kit. Gee my wet kit and my Pro 125 both have provisions to test LP. Then you have companies wanting to pay peanuts for for experienced techs. The industry is often it's own worst enemy.
    Leo
  • tom_49
    tom_49 Member Posts: 267
    advertising

    Keith,

    Good point about the drug co's. They dont even tell you what their stuff is treating. But weve all seen it.


    Im not to concerned w/ the manufacturers selling to the consumers.
    Most people have no clue about how to install and would much rather have a pro install it. I just think the manufactures need to get their stuff in front of the public so they are even aware it exists.

    I know tons of contractors who dont install mod/con boilers. If they dont know about these machines how on earth are the HOs going to.

    Once people realize whats out there they will start to show an interest. How many of your customers actually have heard about the products your selling them, ( "how do you say that" Veysman", "Buder-who?" )I bet not many. but I bet they all heard of Viagra. How? ads.

    We can show them when they call for est. or sevice, but why not go to them w/ it.

    Brand awareness. Why I agree that the best system is the one thats installed and service correctly, alot can be said about brand awareness. Lets face it , there are brands you guys wouldnt install. isnt there? People dont buy Corvettes, or Boston Whalers,or whatever else top "name brand" because of the dealership. They like the product.


    Attention manufacuters: Smart advertizing doesnt cost, it PAY$.
  • tom_49
    tom_49 Member Posts: 267
    tv ad

    > An area P&H company is doing cable TV ads

    > featuring Biasi boilers. They show the triple

    > pass and mention efficiency and oil savings etc.



  • tom_49
    tom_49 Member Posts: 267
    tv ad



    I think thats a great idea, I hope they are getting some co-op $$.

    Watch to see if the ad runs for an extended amount of time, if it does, its working.
  • Steamhead (in transit)
    Steamhead (in transit) Member Posts: 6,688
    Depends on where you're installing the unit

    In older buildings such as we find in Baltimore, it can be impossible to find a way to vent a mod-con boiler that will meet Codes and the manufacturer's instructions. We've seen where others have played fast-and-loose with this; we'll probably read about it in the papers or see it on TV news at some point. Then the lawyers will get involved.....

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • will smith_4
    will smith_4 Member Posts: 259
    Well, the other side of that coin-

    Is that steam and hydronic systems get ripped out every day by companies that have never taken the time to understand how the systems worked to begin with, and were at least clever enough to go in and convince the customer that they would be better off with high efficiency forced air with the option of coooling systems. That, in my opinion, is a reflection of a lack of training in hydronics overall in the tradeschools/colleges nationwide. What we don't understand, we destroy. A tech goes out to troubleshoot a two pipe steam system with no clue as to what they're looking at, calls back to a salesperson who two months prior was selling used cars saying the system is shot (when it might be a failed ANYTHING), next thing you know, the system gets ripped out for forced air.
    When I first started in my trade, I thought the smartest eggs worked on the newest equipment. I realize now that the smartest eggs work on the oldest stuff-that's more challenging to keep going!
  • Steamhead (in transit)
    Steamhead (in transit) Member Posts: 6,688
    More to it than that

    tearing out old systems is labor-intensive. Shady contractors see many dollar signs in tear-outs, that's why they push scorched-air so much.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
  • Jeff Lawrence_25
    Jeff Lawrence_25 Member Posts: 746
    Frank

    Are you sure it's shady contractors or ignorant ones?

    There are too many people in the world even now that don't go to the effort to learn about HW heat and therefore think it's bad.

    Current customer could have had heating put in the FA system he's having installed in his house for a few dollars more, but is going with adding on to his HW system because he sees the value, even though the cost is nearly 10 times the cost.
  • amhwrite
    amhwrite Member Posts: 6
    Too high tech?

    Steve, one company too many you say? Ha! You would flip if you were in my area. You don't know how many guys say that the new stuff is just too complicated! At least if a thermocouple goes bad in the winter you can get one and change it quickly! That zone valve is just one more thing that can go bad! Why put on a complicated T-Stat! Here's all you need! And the classic, I'm from the old school! If you can't tighten it with a wrench, solder it, or tap on it, to get it to go, its high tech to them! I recently was involved with a water heater replacement referred by a friend of a friend. Long story short, two new heaters in four or five years, a new forced air furnace a couple of years ago side wall vented, leaving only the water heater in an old masonry chimney. The condensation and basement dampness were obvious, my explanation of why was accepted at the time. I offered several options, from new instantaneous, so on, to my least expensive was lining the chimney and a new standard water heater. They'll get back to me. Never heard from them, so I asked the friend that referred them what happened. They felt that I was honest and probably an excellent craftsman, but they thought that I wanted to do the job “too good.” Another plumber told them that a standard water heater like they had was all that they needed, and that there was no such thing as a chimney being too big, basements are damp places! He further told them that if they installed the "high tech" equipment that I first recommended, that they would be asking for nothing but trouble! Those babies break down and it’s hard to get part in the winter time! Always the winter time! I give their new water heater two years and they may finally have the job done "too good!" Or another guy will just change that one blaming the greedy manufacturer that wouldn't replace their junk under warranty! How can you compete with that? I may go broke not getting the jobs, but, I won't give up trying!
  • Steamhead (in transit)
    Steamhead (in transit) Member Posts: 6,688
    I've had the experience of

    having been on the job site when the scorched-air/heat-pump pushers show up. To hear them talk, especially if the owner is out of the room, I have had to conclude that they're shady. I've had fun listening to them without telling them who I am, then blowing them out of the water when I talk to the owner. Not gonna mention names here though......

    It might be more ignorance further south where there's lots of FA and less hydronic, but with roughly half of the pre-WW2 housing stock in Baltimore having steam and the other half hot-water, I highly doubt they're that ignorant.

    To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"
This discussion has been closed.