Buffer tank

Joe_55

Brad: your verbal sketch was spot on and again thank you very much for your knowledgeable reply ( by the way I may need to syphon some more of that knowledge down the road for my own heating system.)

When it comes to cyberspace I too find myself in a grey area with minimal expertise,However I believe if you are able to scan your sketch,give it a title and save it in your files,You can click on attachment at the bottom of each message form, that will open up your files click on your sketch and it will appear at the bottom of your post.

I am sure there are others here that will be kind enough to add to or emend this.

Happy new year
Bill.

Sam_11

buffer tank

I am considering adding a buffer tank in order to increase the water volume for a small radiant slab (4 loops 1/2" pex)1,200 square feet. The boiler in this set up is an ultra 155. Would you pipe it on the supply or return and what type of tank would you use?

Brad White_15

Depends

If you are using this as part of a conventional "direct to radiant" system, I would pipe it on the return, reason being that if you piped it on the supply, you would have to wait that much longer to see hot water at your emitters (slab, radiators or anything else you have).

Think of it as a hydronic piggy bank that you draw from, what you do not use on the first pass is a deposit and once warm you draw from it while presumably the boiler is between cycles. Prolongs the condensation period too, but if direct to radiant you probably will always be below the dewpoint anyway.

My own is piped into the return side in parallel to the main via closelyspacedtees and a circulator activated when the HWR comes back too warm. Otherwise, when the HWR is cool enough it all goes back to the boiler directly. That's one example. My own tank is a Super-Stor Ultra (HTS brand name but what a coincidence.) It is a storage tank only, no heat exchanger, primarily designed to increase domestic hot water volume, but used strictly in the heating system in my case.

If you are using it as a "hydronic decoupler", then it would be on the supply side as a mixing vessel, primary from the boiler, secondary to the emitters. Not sure if the Super-Stor has available secondary tappings necessary to use as a decoupler though.

My $0.02,

Brad

Joe_55

buffer tank

Brad: very interesting setup,not sure i understand how you have it piped in the return and parallel to the main, could you include a sketch,and what controls the pump and where is this control installed?. What determins the size of the tank is bigger better? I enjoy all your posts thanks Bill.

Wayco Wayne_2

I'm curious

what is the heat load on this slab and what water temps are required? WW

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

Sam_11

Max heat load calculations call for 46,000 BTU and set at 138degrees.

Sam_11

Sam_11

Do you have pictures? Attached are some of mine. One reason that I am considering the buffer tank is because the system was short cycling. I was able to control this by adjusting the high heat / boiler modulation.

Brad White_9

Thanks Bill

I probably could use some help posting sketches to the site (another subject) but let me try verbally for now:

My house is piped 2-pipe reverse return and has two 1-inch branches, one per side of the house. TRV's on Runtal and cast iron radiators and some limited floor radiant.

After all of my HWR is collected in a 1.25-inch return main, I have a strap-on Johnson reverse-acting aquastat. Shortly after this, about 18 inches downstream, are a pair of closely spaced tees. The first line goes to the buffer tank via a Taco 007. The return from the tank goes to the second main tee with a flow-check in the branch line.

When the HWR comes back too warm (125* I keep adjusting it), the 007 comes on and prolongs the condensing period by emptying the tank of whatever temperature is within it. On start-up this is close to room/basement temperature but is only used when the HWR might thwart my condensing mode. When the return temperature drops to an acceptably chilly level the pump stops. Simple as could be.


(To additionally confuse you, the return line from the tank to the main has another set of tees which divert flow to some basement radiators for an occassional boost down there. I use it infrequently so is via a manual thermostat, nothing fancy. But it too prolongs the condensing and does lessen the cycling.)

I have a Monitor MZ-25 which as you know is on-off, no modulation, so this was my attempt to prolong a cycle while banking some "coasting time" between cycles. The tank is a 40-gallon Super-Stor Ultra.

Any help you can give on posting sketches (embarrasingly simple I am sure, but you all do it so well!) would be appreciated.

Best,

Brad

Sam_11

Do you have any pictures. Attached are some of my setup. One of the reasons that I am considering adding the buffer tank is because the system originally was short cycling. I was able to fix this by adjusting the high fire / boiler modulation settings, but this is probaby just a band-aid?? What do you think?

hr

Sounds like a lot of boiler

for 1200 square feet??

hot rod

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

Joe_55

Sam_11

I forgot to mention that the boiler also handles a combination baseboard / radiators and yet to be installed a snow melt system.

Sam_11

Sam_11

Are you able to take pictures with a digital camera and save them to a file in your computer?

Brad White_9

I could do that

but the angle from which I would take the shot would not make it as clear as a diagram would. I do not have a digital camera (yet) but do get film processed with a companion CD which works well. May take me a day or so...

Good point though!

Sam_11

I downloaded the manual for the superstor storage tank and I see that it also as supply and return for the boiler. Are you using these? or did you plug them in your setup?

Brad White_9

Mine is

just a storage tank with only three (3) 3/4" tappings. The upper one is for a T&P valve when used for domestic HW storage. No heat exchanger hence no other tappings. All of the wizardry is in the piping.

[Deleted User]

Agree with Hot Rod

Agree with Hot Rod, sounds like a lot of boiler. It needs to be throttled down!! I installed an Ultra 105 and a plus 40 indirect this past spring in my 1700 sqft two story house. My heat loss calc is 48,056 btu's. The old cast iron boiler I replaced was a 140K btu's. Talk about oversizing! The house has fin tube baseboard, I zoned it upstairs/downstairs, and left 2 spare spots for additional zones down the road. I throttled the 105 down to 60% which is about 63K btu's. I changed some of the other parameter settings. My max water temp running thru the baseboards is 170 deg vice 190 deg and the condensate pump is still pumping at 170 deg supply temp. My monthly gas usage last year was 100ccf, this year with the Ultra I'm at 67ccf a month.

hr

A pretty big mismatch

when you try to run a small zone like that off a boiler sized for snowmelt.

Here is how I did a similar.

I used the Munchkin to heat the tank side of this Weil tank in tank indirect. I pulled ther snowmelt from the small outer tank, as my glycoled loop.

This way I had the 53 gallon capacity to buffer and pull my small radiant loops, and the snowmelt side on it's own loop.

The snowmelt has priority, as the home has 4 furnaces for backup and snowmelting is a rare occurance here in SW Missouri.

On another job I had a large DHW load for a laundry, with a very small radiant load. I piped an Ultra 230 directly to the Burnham 80 gallon indirect. Then with closely spaced tees pulled the radiant off that loop. The tank runs the boiler to 140 with the indirect aquastat. Just enough buffer to keep the cycling down.

I've done other Munchkins with basic electric water heater tanks, and a few MZ's.

hot rod

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"