microbubble scrubbers

Mike Reavis_2

I have used a few of these, and am for the most part satisfied with the performance. I am wondering about their operation. Are they able to get air that is trapped in a section of the system to dissolve into the water, and then be eliminated, or must the air bubbles actually pass through the separator to be eliminated?

Mike

Ken_8

Being the classic cynic...

that I am, I suggest the so-called "microbubble scrubbers" are a great solution to a problem that does not exist!

Any properly sized and located air purger and simple air vent will remove air from the system.

Using a boiler with internal baffles that allows the hottest and slowest flow water point to be where the air is "caught" - has always been better than an external air separater; be it micro or plain jane variety. This is because a principal of basic physics suggests the air is released best the higher the water temperature (and there is no hotter spot than inside the boiler block itself) AND, where the water runs slowest. That point will always be within the boiler block itself.

The Weil McLain boilers we use have the air scoop built in. The good thing? It's free.

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

Mike Reavis_2

I agree,

> that I am, I suggest the so-called "microbubble

> scrubbers" are a great solution to a problem that

> does not exist!

>

> Any properly sized and located

> air purger and simple air vent will remove air

> from the system.

>

> Using a boiler with

> internal baffles that allows the hottest and

> slowest flow water point to be where the air is

> "caught" - has always been better than an

> external air separater; be it micro or plain jane

> variety. This is because a principal of basic

> physics suggests the air is released best the

> higher the water temperature (and there is no

> hotter spot than inside the boiler block itself)

> AND, where the water runs slowest. That point

> will always be within the boiler block

> itself.

>

> The Weil McLain boilers we use have

> the air scoop built in. The good thing? It's

> free.

>

> _A

> HREF="http://www.heatinghelp.com/getListed.cfm?id=

> 68&Step=30"_To Learn More About This

> Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in

> "Find A Professional"_/A_

Mike Reavis_2

I agree,

but I had a few jobs that I wanted to be absolutely sure that I delivered systems without noise. (The previous system was noisy--I got the job because I guaranteed them it would go away) Do you have an answer to my original question?

Mike

Robert O'Connor_6

I think the air has to pass thru the scrubber.

Of course if you somehow had an air pocket in the system eventually the system water might absorb the air. Just like a compression tank gets water logged. I think it would take a while.

I agree with Ken . Airscoops in boilers and and external scoops piped properly are effective in most systems.

Spirovents etc just do it faster

Regards,

Robert

ME

DanHolohan

It has to

pass through. If you're using a non-diaphragm compression tank you can keep the air in the tank by using a B&G Airtrol Tank Fitting.

Unknown

The Weil Mclain Gold

we use , the 3L is designed perfectly for air elimination in the block itself . We use the 1 1/2 inch tapping high on the front of the boiler for our supply and cap the supply tapping on top . The 1/2 inch tapping on top is for air removal and setup this way there aint no chance the system will bind up . Beauty in it's simplicity , and it's free .

Joe Mattiello

Joe Mattiello
Technical Service Technician

Joe Mattiello

Taco, 4900 series

Will remove micro bubbles as small as .0018 from the system.
Remove air which has dissolved in the system's water.
Remove air from places where an air vent can not be installed.
Remove and separate solid particles from the flow. Please see the attachment 4900 catalog for all the features, and benefits.
Joe Mattiello
Technical Service Technician
401-942-8000 X 484

Ken_8

The answer to your question...

"Are they able to get air that is trapped in a section of the system to dissolve into the water, and then be eliminated, or must the air bubbles actually pass through the separator to be eliminated"? is

That depends!

If the air trapped area gets no flow (like a mono-flo circuit that is air bound) the answer is no. The system will not "absorb" that air and transfer it back to an air scoop - be it a micro bubble type, airtrol fitting or baffled boiler block. At least not for a long long time.

However, if there is flow back to the boiler - AND NO WAY FOR ADDITIONAL AIR TO BE INTRODUCED, then after some time, the air will be absorbed into the cooler water and be returned to the slow and hotter point and come out of solution and be liberated into the air via some venting mechanism.

I assume the time it takes to chase all air out is dependent on many variables, e.g., how hot the boiler/water, how slow the flow, how much air is in there, what means of venting, both static (fill) pressure and dynamic pressure and of course the circ./pump dynamics and location/orientation.

You are aware of the Gil Carlsen/Dan Holohan designs of pumping away right? Pumping away from the PONPC that is?

If not, have I got a book for you(:-o)

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

hr

Much quicker

at doing their job than a air scoop, or "wide spot" in the road, that some boilers still offer.

This can be important in radiant jobs where you may have thousands, or tens of thousands feet of tube to "clear"

Also systems, like radiant, that operate at lower temperatures give up the air slower, as high temperatures cause the air to come out of solution quicker.

Is it just me or did micro bubble resorbers get popular about the same time as the radiant revolution?

They also are a good fix for noisey systems where regular scoops fall short, although it is more often a location issue.

Check out the Spiro vent demo at a trade show near you. hard to deny the micro bubble scrub-ability when you see one through clear pipes. Not unlike the Weil steam trailer demo Seeing is believing.

hot rod

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

BillW@honeywell

The \"metal brush\"coalescer...

in our "Powervent" is very effective at helping microbubbles become big enough bubbles to collect at the top of the control and be eliminated. Also, the larger chamber slows the water down enough that it encourages all the bubbles to coalesce. Good boiler design, "Pumping Away", and a good quality Powervent are a combo that is hard to beat. Tech info at http://hbctechlit.honeywell.com.

Bob Bona_4

that demo

made me a believer the second the hand pump started:)

Darin Cook_3

Swing Open Door

Ron, How exactly Does that swing open door, swing open?

Unknown

Gee , Bob

I guess you might have to go the extra mile and take the whole door off with the burner - considering it's located 4 feet off the floor , sandwiched between 2 brick walls and a steel I beam , hidden by a cover in the kitchen no less . As a guess I would think a good 20 minutes to remove it for cleaning . But hey , it beats cleaning what was up there to begin with . I take it you never seen a boiler in a Levitt home ?

Darin Cook_3

Sorry

But knowing that the WGO cleans from the top down, the clearance looks alittle "close". If you make it too hard to clean for your guys then it won't get cleaned. Yes, I have worked in Levitt style homes many times. A Buderus G-115 makes for a very easy to clean boiler especially in that type install. Gee, maybe taking an extra 20 minutes to pipe it properly would be in the companys best interest and the customers.

Robert O'Connor_6

With all due respect

I don't see a Buderus in that application. They don't have coils and they are large.

see Buderus 115 specs

http://www.buderus.net/literature/G115-CB-01.pdf

My hats off to all who work in Leavitt Homes!!

regards

Robert

Mark Eatherton1

That is what they claim, however....

In my own home, I have a micro bubble resorber. I have a simple one pipe system. There was a "Rogue bubble" working its way through my system from day one. It moved like the wind. I intentionally set up the first radiator on my system to "trap" any rogue bubbles working they way around my system. Didn't work.

The MBR was a part of the original system. Didn't work.

I eventually ended up inducing a few ounces of my favorite (Dawn!) dish detergent into the system in a frustrated effort to eliminate the roving gurgle.

No more gurgle...

Corporately, we NEVER use MBR's, and we've NEVER had an air issue in ANY of the thousands of systems we've installed, except one job where a major manufacturer "donated" an MBR for our free use. It failed. They replaced the internal working parts and it started working again, much to their credit. I won't mention any names because they're still in the R&D phase of their product.

To my estimation, MBR's were introduced in response to "air problems" in existing systems. 99% of those problems had to do with improper design and set up in the first place. If you're pumping away from the boiler and the expansion tank, a conventional air seperator will work just fine.

I have inside information from extremely reliable sources that tell me that when the system shuts down, ma nature takes over and balances out the O2 content of the water anyway...

To each his own...but for my money, a properly placed scoop does the trick every time. Or in Kennys case, a built in air seperator at the boiler works just fine. Unfortunately, the Euro boiler makers I work with don't do it that way so we throw an additinal 15$ to make it work right.

JMHO

ME



To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

Boilerpro_3

I'm with you

I have stopped using microbubble air separators on nearly all my systems. I have found the simple B&G IAS does alot better job than the typical air scoops. Its a completely different design than the scoops. To me all the micorbubble unit do is clear the system a little faster. The only place I use tend to use them is on divertor tee systems where the air can easily get trapped in the units. However, even then, I have found that even if a baseboard does get air bound, it eventually frees up as the water absorbs the air through the supply an return piping to the unit.

Boilerpro

leo g_13

we

have a couple of inspectors, that will not allow us to use the scoops unless we have those pesky little auto vents all over the place. "these spiro types bring the air to them!".

it always astounds me that i have to get inspected by people that don't have 1/10 of the training or certification that i have......:(

leo g

To Learn More About This Professional, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Professional"

Mike Kraft_2

boilerpro.............

The EAS is a micro scrubber.Unless I'm missing something.I did use them years back but Hot Rod passionately refers to them as a "boat anchor":) Compared to say a Spiro vent he is dead balls acurate!But it looks like the same animal.Compared to a baffled style air scoop.Which I think some installers are calling a scoop.

cheese

Man one of these days I'll get it.Cut and paste

http://fhaspapp.ittind.com/literature/files/573.pdf - Cached

Don't follow the attachment..it doesnt go anywhere

Larry (from OSHA)

about that EAS air eliminator

Looking at figure #2 on the EAS page,I'm wondering if you MUST have an Airtrol Tank Fitting on the compression tank if you pipe that way, or can you just connect directly to the tank? Also, would it be possible to use a taco air separator (or spirovent or other type) piped like that.

A separate question--can cavitation occur at 170* with 20 pounds system pressure? Or is it air coming out of solution in the pump volute that I'm hearing?

Thanks,

Larry

Unknown

Hey Bob

Being in Levitt homes many times , you happen to have any pics of a Buderus in a space that tight ? A G-115 ? You are kidding ?

Aren't you ?

Man I hope so .

You think with a few thousand accounts just like this we didn't check to see which boilers would fit up there ?

You think with a few thousand accounts we would install a boiler up there that was a **** to get to when cleaning , when there might be a more suitable fit ?

I don't know who you work for , but if the boiler needs to be cleaned , it gets cleaned . The top is wide open , and if needs be , the burner can be pulled .

" An extra 20 minutes to pipe it properly " ? Hell , give me 4 more hours and I couldn't pipe it any better to access the swing door , and put the cover back up . Please enlighten me as to a more proper way to do it , and in one day . Or were you under the assumption we would ever leave our customers without heat and hot water for 2 days ?

C'mon Bob , lets see these immensly accesible installs you refer to . Up on the shelf .

And when you're done tracking down the pics of these supposed installs ( which I know are not coming ) , give me some directions to this perfect place you're living in pal .

Robert O'Connor_3

Joe?


I can really see that on W/M, Burnham, Smith, Peerless,et.al., 3,4,5,6,7 section boilers!!!! Talk about upsell.....

Jed

Robert O'Connor_3

EAS vs EASBjr

I like this design for residential.

http://fhaspapp.ittind.com/literature/files/1136.pdf

Jed

p.s. I have Kim @ FIA to thank for bringing it to my attention.

Boilerpro_3

MK, thats's IAS, not EAS

IAS is B&G's inline air seperator. The EAS is the microbubble unit. The IAS uses a multi chamber design with a port, instead of just an inclined plane. Not sure how it works, but it seems to work alot better than scoops. The EAS is big and heavy, but really does the job and can handle very high flow rates.

Boilerpro