Boiler Choic

Dave_19

Got 3 estimates, 3 different boilers.

Weil-McLain CGi-5
Dunkirk Plymouth Xtreme PWX-5V
Buderus G124X/32

I'd like any comments on pros and cons of each boiler. The efficiencies are similar, costs vary, but are reasonable. Thanks.

Steamhead

You're likely to get

as many different opinions as there are Wall participants. W-M, Dunkirk and Buderus are all good products. But the installation is just as important as the boiler. Have you checked out the Find a Contractor page of this site?

To Learn More About This Contractor, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Contractor"

kf_2

Dave,

think about which one of those boilers keep the heat in the boiler (where it belongs) and not in the basement.

ie. take a look at the thickness of insulation surrounding the water vessels of each boiler.

The combustion (AFUE) efficiencies may be similar, but where does that efficiently heated water go after its been heated, into your heating system or into your basement.

Just some food for thought.

kf

clammy

which one

i,ve installed mc lean and buderus and i,de hate to be european but i,de go with the buderus there a excellent boiler and make controls that are talor made for ther4e boilers and price wise there a much better value for your dollar the other plus is a much better insulation jacket and leveling legs on the unit but im a fan of there stuff it,s never let me down and every one i've done there's been no promblem with ,i even installed one in my mom and dads as a present.good luck

Paul Pollets

This One's A Bud

Buderus has a better casting and more insulation to reduce standby losses. Their integral Logamatic control makes it a very efficient appliance.

To Learn More About This Contractor, Click Here to Visit Their Ad in "Find A Contractor"