Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.

Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

Replacing Arco Convectors with Column Radiators - Good or Terrible idea?

Options

Im considering replacing Arco Convectors (hot water) with standard old radiators because we like the look of them much better than the cover on the convectors. I realize it will be a lot of work and plan to do some calculations due to different size of materials, but am wondering what opinions are out there. Has anyone ever done this?


pictures consistent of currently installed Arco convector and the radiators (once refurbished and sized) to be installed (that are being pulled from a building I recently purchased


Thank you!

2792234047627762769.jpeg IMG_3889.jpeg

Comments

  • Steamhead
    Steamhead Posts: 19,020

    It can be done. But……………

    First, the system where the rads are "being pulled" is Vapor (ultra-low-pressure two-pipe steam) not hot-water. You'd have to change the piping arrangements in the house and maybe remove plugs and bushings in the radiators to make everything fit.

    Second, the radiator in the first pic cannot be taken apart easily, if at all. It is assembled with right/left threaded nipples rather than push nipples and rods. This requires special tools which might have to be custom-made. And if you do get it apart, it will probably leak when you put it back together. Ask me how I know……………

    If that were my building I'd keep the steam, do a heat-loss calculation on your house, and find radiators of proper sizes for the heat losses.

    Co-Founder, All Steamed Up, Inc.

    Semi-retired

    Baltimore, MD, USA

  • EBEBRATT-Ed
    EBEBRATT-Ed Posts: 21,353

    @Steamhead I think the system with the convectors is a HW job. He want's to use the steam rads he is pulling out to replace the convectors and keep the system water.

    I don't see an issue I would flush the rad internally first and you will probably end up over radiated. You would have to do a Heat Loss determine each rooms load determine your water temp and then put in different size rads (or use TRVs maybe) to get the correct flow. It's going to be more of a project that you might envision.

  • Steamhead
    Steamhead Posts: 19,020

    It is. I was referring to the other building when I said keep the steam.

    Co-Founder, All Steamed Up, Inc.

    Semi-retired

    Baltimore, MD, USA

    EBEBRATT-Ed
  • mattmia2
    mattmia2 Posts: 18,431

    if you change all of them to ci radiators then it should work well if you match the radiators to the heat loss of each room. if you only replace some convectors with radiators, the radiators and convectors will heat and cool at different rates and you will have trouble balancing the system.

    bburd
  • Beagle96
    Beagle96 Posts: 3

    i would love to keep the steam. Unfortunately, its the system that Ray Wolfarth visited that we determined need so much work, its not practical to keep. It hasnt been maintained properly and definitely had a lot of knuckleheads do many wrong things that Im not confident in the safety without 20K+ in investment in the 100 vapor system. I had significant trouble getting anyone to come look at it let alone give me a quote or be willing to work on it. I am having 4 new gas furnaces and ductwork installed so I can split the bills to eat tenant in the building rather than carrying the cost.

    My hope was to be able to repurpose these in my own home by retrofitting, refurbishing, and adjusting (such as moving one pipe to the other side, adding bleeders, etc), but its starting to sound like an even larger project than I already anticipated as large. The idea of finding appropriately sized hot water rads that I don’t have to break apart sounds more appealing.

    The industrial look of the covers for the convectors doesn’t go with the look of what we are trying to achieve. Maybe we will consider replacing the covers, but dont want to lose the stack effect with decorative panels.

    I keep hearing that you need more columns on rads to replace the convectors, but my intuition says the (currently) steam rads would over heat the house due to sheer surface area, even though they aren’t doing any convection heating.

    One other consideration is that weve had trouble heating the house when its 0 degrees outside. It drops from a 68 set point down to 58-62. To address this BEFORE any heating changes, we had new windows installed and next air sealing and insulating the attic (it only has 4 inches of blown in and I have someone coming to do a blower door test to see our loss). Once that is done, this may just become a aesthetic choice. My main concern was if it was even reasonable to consider or if Im barking up the wrong tree here.

  • Steamhead
    Steamhead Posts: 19,020

    @Beagle96 , do a heat-loss on the house. That is the starting point for any such work. If you have trouble heating the place, either the radiators are too small, or the boiler is too small or not working properly, or there is another problem that needs fixing.

    Co-Founder, All Steamed Up, Inc.

    Semi-retired

    Baltimore, MD, USA

  • PC7060
    PC7060 Posts: 1,982
    edited October 17

    If you like the look of the column radiators don’t let concern of “too much heat” bother you, you can add a TRV to control output.

    I have 19 columns radiators of various sizes; 90% of which are installed with TRV.

    More radiation may allow you to run a MODCON boiler with ODR controlled water temp. My house runs max SWT of 115F at temp of 5F.

  • bburd
    bburd Posts: 1,341
    edited October 17

    If you have trouble heating the house in extremely cold weather, insufficient radiation is not likely to be the problem. Are all supply valves open? Has the system been purged of air, and is the gauge pressure high enough to fill the top floor convectors? What are the supply and return water temperatures? A simple increase in the high limit setting may be all you need. Up to a 20°F difference between supply and return is normal for older systems; a greater difference may indicate insufficient flow. If the system never reaches the high limit setting and shuts off the burner while the circulator continues to run, check the actual firing rate — use the test dials on the gas meter and compare to the boiler's input rating.

    —
    Bburd