Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.

Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

If our community has helped you, please consider making a contribution to support this website. Thanks!

First Post Introduction / Navien NFB boiler or combi experiences? / Boiler Favorites?

Options
Hello everyone. My name is T-mo. I've been involved with the hydronics trade for 30+ years. Trained by my uncle starting at 13 as a plumber/pump and well/ heating tech. in Maine. I went to art school but found my passion was more inline with mechanical engineering. Did the first two years of school but ran out of money. I've done some sheet-metal fabrication, Air system design and have been an HVAC service tech for a few stints. EPA certified. I ran my own business for 12 years but hated having to find train and run employees, all the desk work and treadmills that come with keeping a crew working. I'm currently a solo hydronics contractor focusing on service in Sonoma, CA. I love diagnostics and resolving long standing problems with existing system. I like the role of detective and engineer, though I'm neither. I enjoy helping people and being worth what I charge. I can geek out on efficiency and tech but have learned simplicity and durability are very valuable. I've done a few heat pump hydronic systems and want to be on that front for new system design and ground up installs.

Anyone have any experiences with Navien's fire tube boiler-NFB or combi-NFC? I'm not a Navien fan but their fire tube seems good. I have a few in service without any issues. I like the control interface, setup and programing so far. The on board zone valve control option is without end switches and I find that inexcusable but that's my only grip. Yes, it's big but that will make it easier to work on. It has a great turn down ratio and is fairly quiet most of it's firing capacity. My next fire tube choice would be an IBC and then a Lochinvar. Rinnai as a company is good and I like the I series boilers and their tank-less units are good. What's your take? No giannoni's. Yes, I know some are better than others. HTP? Let's not.

Comments

  • kcopp
    kcopp Posts: 4,739
    Never Navien for me.
    SuperTech
  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,723
    I like the fire tube Weil McLain boilers. Anything is preferable to Navien. 
  • Teemok
    Teemok Posts: 757
    Weil Mclain- I installed when I was training in the late 80's early 90's east coast. Cast iron nat. draft, some oil fired and some mid. efficiency stuff with that used that questionable dark clearish plastic flue material. I'll check them out. Do you know if they make it themselves, is it a collection of others parts or a label change rebrand of another maker? At first glance: 5:1 turn down ratio ??? I'm in a warm climate with customers that want to micro zone every little 2000-6000 btu load space with low mass distribution. Short cycle city. I have to insist they don't do that but they have the money. Maybe it has it's place for some systems.
  • kcopp
    kcopp Posts: 4,739
    I am a big fan of IBC. My go yo the the HC/ SuperFlow unit.
    The SL/ VX are solid units w/ a crazy good control.
  • Teemok
    Teemok Posts: 757
    edited September 2023
    Yes the IBC SL control has a ton of flexibility and features. I think IBC made it. The HC /super flow HX is unique being both copper and aluminum. They are not IBC manufactured they are Intergas. They are ok. I see Rheem owns IBC now. Hope they stay high quality. The block of aluminum hx is a good little buffer against cycling. They had some fan issues years back. I was sure the aluminum fire side hx "pins" would rot away but I haven't found one dead. The older ones I see have the lower hx corroded but still working and well over ten years old.
  • hot_rod
    hot_rod Posts: 28,769
    Mild climates, micro zones, at some point a buffer tank makes sense


    Or one of the HTP tank style heaters, 50 or 80 gallons takes care of micro loads


    Bob "hot rod" Rohr
    trainer for Caleffi NA
    Living the hydronic dream
  • Teemok
    Teemok Posts: 757
    You're right. Some times I do that. That was the design move back when Munchkins were new and so cooL with no HX cleaning notice or instructions and they came with primary only piping diagrams. I tried to make some coffee with those HX grounds but they turned out to magnetic.
  • Late to the party but have been using the NFC series for 6-7 years now I love the product, though we always follow Naviens recommendations and keep the combustion exhaust and intake well separated, air elimination, primary secondary piping and magnetic filter. Clean system with fernox ahead of time then inhibitor.

    Critical parts are very easy to remove in my experience. Some without the dhw hooked up though. Very solid in my opinion and tech support available 7 days a week except Christmas and New years though I have only had to call navien 5 or 6 times in the last 16 years in the trade.

  • Have you ever had to replace a diverter valve in one of the older NCB units? It was in the back left corner and I had to remove the pump to get to it. Took me 3 hours. Technical support has gotten a lot better.

    8.33 lbs./gal. x 60 min./hr. x 20°ΔT = 10,000 BTU's/hour

    Two btu per sq ft for degree difference for a slab
  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,723

    You haven't had any heat exchanger failures? We had a few not last 3 months before the Navien was spraying water from a hole in the heat exchanger. I won't ever recommend another Navien product.

    kcoppoffdutytech
  • I've used the Naiven firetube for an old gravity system that was converted to oil. When the customer wanted to change to natural gas I installed a Navien firetube.

    It was a little less expensive than the Alta and we were trying to stay within the customers budget. Installation was straightforward with piping. It's easy to make a unit strut rack and mount it to that. I thought the configuration and setup was more cumbersome than other manufactures.

    My go to modcon is the Alta, much easier to service and setup using the bluetooth configuration. Navien for me in general is more of a budget boiler. In the right application it's ok, there are better options out there. Not really a fan of the Navien water tube heat exchanger. I think Navien did a good job of marketing and was able to get their products into a lot of supply houses. Thus there claim of being the "best selling" boilers. I usually find that the contractors who install them dabble in hydronics and they really shouldn't be touching boilers.

    Once you take a look at the true cost of let's say Navien vs Alta, the Alta is about just a few hundred dollars more. I've installed a few Naviens at the request of customers, but usually will price the Alta just right so that gets installed.

    Owner of Grunaire Climate Solutions. Check us out under the locate a contractor section. Located in Detroit area.

    Alan (California Radiant) Forbes
  • SuperTech
    SuperTech Posts: 2,723

    @offdutytech I agree that the fire tube boilers are better, but I still won't recommend them after all my bad experiences with Navien.

    It's great to hear that you like the Alta, we are considering installing them but we haven't had the opportunity to install one yet. I know they are supposed to have some nice features and be easy to setup. Hopefully they are good quality. I know US Boilers/Burnham products can be hit or miss. They make some great boilers like the MPO/Megasteam and then have some real duds like the Independence and V7 boilers.

  • @SuperTech

    I had the chance to attend a Burnham factory tour and training with my supplier this summer. What did it for me is how simple the Alta is work on. All three sides come off the boiler, watching how they built them and the simplicity was key. My local Burnham rep is great to work with so the support I get was a huge plus. The Velocity Boiler works is the same boiler just different sticker on the front panel. So if your local supplier deals with the Velocity line it's the same boiler. They are both assembled in the same building.

    100% on the Megasteam! Navien for me is just a product line to compete with the market and give an apples to apples comparison for the customer. Not having bluetooth or an app for startup on the Navien is a miss for me. I like to have a report on how the boiler was setup to avoid finger pointing when someone pushes the buttons and changes things after I'm done with the job. Love a Viessman, but my supplier dosnt carry them and the one that does just not a fan of their support and other products.

    Owner of Grunaire Climate Solutions. Check us out under the locate a contractor section. Located in Detroit area.