Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.
Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

Mixing valve in multizone radiant heating - connect to its own return or joint return is fine?

apolyakov
apolyakov Member Posts: 6
edited September 6 in Radiant Heating
Hello


There are two schemas here - 3 zone radiant heat with mixing valves for each zone. At first both looked to me equivalent, but are they really? Can points "A" and "B" be swapped, i.e. so that the zone 3 instead of taking cold water from "its own" return line (left picture) first joins its own return with the rest of the zones and then taking that (right picture)?

Maybe it's a naive thinking, but for the right side picture my worry is that zone 3 might be taking water from two zones on the left whereas its own return will be going straight to the tank, so the two pictures are NOT equivalent and in some situations right picture can produce wrong results.

More generic question, can I join all returns from all zones first and then feed joint return to each zone mixing valve instead of feeding each zone return to its mixing valve first and then joining after (first two zones on both pictures)?

Thank you

Comments

  • GroundUp
    GroundUp Member Posts: 1,474
    The return temps are almost certainly going to be different between zones, and your second diagram would have water flowing both directions between A and B when multiple zones are running. The first diagram is much better, but you surely don't have to loop over the top like that.