Looking for Mechanical Prints

Paul Rohrs_14

Wallies,

I am putting together a few slides in our new Hydronic Sizing & Boiler Application School that involve dissecting commercial jobs. I am looking for 5-6 jobs that have a few non-ideal piping arrangements so that the we (as a group)can learn to identify problem areas and make recommended corrective actions.

I am not looking to disparage any firm so I am not going to include individual names, firms, or regions where the prints originated from. If included, I will edit out that type of info.

The goal is strictly to develop hydronic CSI skills and corrective actions.

Any and all help is appreciated.

Best,

Paul

Rich_49

I will look through the pile of plans I labeled as trash . If any are still here i will forward . Of course you must Redact them for obvious reasons . Plenty of trash has seen my table and plenty of heated discussions with M.Es followed by the advice to write their University and ask for a refund .

Paul Rohrs_14

Thank you Rich, that is greatly appreciated.

Rich_49

Paul ,

please PM me with address to forward to if in fact there are any glaring examples of stupidity here .

Tinman

The last piping schematic from mechanical engineer I received was woefully wrong. I'll scan and email it to you.