Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit

Indirect water heater and control

JTM Member Posts: 1
I have a peerless boiler with an internal coil that provides hot water. I have hard water (12 – 13 grains of hardness, 204-221 ppm) and the coil calcifies every 4 years or so (at $800 a pop). The local heating company is recommending an indirect water heater to solve the problem. A couple of questions:

1) Will this truly solve the problem -- or is there a better solution? Will I still get calcification within the indirect system itself and/or piping?

2) They are recommending the Buderus S32 (S120) and the Crown Megastor 40 at over $400 more -- are both capable units? is the Megastor worth $400 more?

3) Should I replace my older control box with a "cold start" model ($330 more) or a Beckett Aquastart ($398 more)?

Thanks so much
This discussion has been closed.