Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit

Small renovation on existing boiler "best" option


I am currently in the middle of a renovation that is adding a unconditioned garage, and an office/passthrough partially below grade and a bathroom at grade. West side of garage and office/passthrough are 4' under grade and east side is at grade. Basement is not heated at this time, but I did put a design load 68 deg.

I have an existing non-condensing 125k BTU slantfin boiler running @180. Grundfos UPS 15-42 8622. Cast iron rads throughout the rest of the 1931 house. Existing house is only approx 1500 fin sqft. New office/passthrough is 265 sqft, Bath 49sqft.

I did do a heatload via loopcad Minneapolis zone -8 designed temp and also checked edr of existing iron as a rough comparison.

What I am getting is the bath @ 1198 btu/hr (bath 10' ceiling others 8'), passthrough @4027 and office @3044. The lower rooms seem higher than I would have expected due to partial below grade but they do face masonry walls (insulated R20 however) and have partial ceiling exposure.

Anyway, what I am struggling with is the design/choice between in-slab and panel rad. In any case I was going to put these new areas on a single manifold with a temp valve (either static or a taco i-valve - suggestions?).

With in slab I was looking at delta10 with water @120. I would have taco 007-ZF5-3IFC, mixing static or taco i-series I075T3R-1, then manifold. Loops as in attachments, trv on other house rads.

If I went panel I was thinking delta 20 @140. I would probably do a mixing valve either static or taco i-series I075T3R-1 and swap circulator to Grundfos alpha 15-55. Panel rads for new areas TrV on all rads in house.

As an FYI, while the current boiler is functional I know a replacement will be required within 10 years. Also, given the current BTU capacity of cast iron, I believe water in the new boiler can be run @140 without issue, given our overall home improvements. LoopCad estimates total BTU of home @ 61487.

I am struggling with the two options given the small space, the future need for boiler and the trade-offs between the in-slab and panel options. The bathroom is an oft-used space, the passageway/office not as much. I also am I bit concerned with the finality of the in-slab radiant and system adjustability.

In my "dreams" bathroom would have in-slab, passage with panel rads but that is making for a more complex system. I even thought a electric heating pad in bath floor with larger towel-warmer or smaller panel rad might be option in bath.

Any thoughts/opinions here? Anything would be helpful.

This discussion has been closed.