Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.
Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.
Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

Phase Out Natural Draft Tank-Style Gas Hot Water Heaters!

This style is the most popular in the US, but is horribly inefficient, potentially dangerous, and almost guaranteed to rust out within 15 years.

Here's a good article on the subject with lots of good comments:

<a href="http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/guest-blogs/get-rid-your-gas-water-heater">http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/guest-blogs/get-rid-your-gas-water-heater</a>

But the jury is still out on what to replace it with. In a new, energy efficient home with a low space heating load, I would use a Split Heat Pump Water Heater when they become available. That way I don't need to pay for a gas tap or that pesky $12/month service fee. The house can be all-electric, and I can make up the electrical usage with PV as costs come down.

What to do in an older home with gas service? The existing gas forced air furnace remains the cheapest way to heat a house like this. Gas is now projected to stay cheap for the next ten years, maybe more. Solar is probably worth it, but you still need a backup source of heat, and in a house like this, gas is probably the best fuel choice.

I'm thinking about an electric tank coupled to a cheap outdoor Aquastar. These units are a bit finicky, but with the right pump, it will be predictable and reliable because it won't see variable flowrates. Of course, the electric elements are unused while gas is cheaper than electric resistance. An outdoor unit because that eliminates a big hole in the house. I think that the storage tank will last 30 years, because I believe that the gas-fired tanks actually rust from the outside in. Water from the flame condenses on the bottom of the tank and rusts it out. Anyone else agree with this theory?

Is anyone doing this? Or is there a better solution for the older inefficient house with gas? Do the outdoor units use too much energy for freeze protection?

There was an error rendering this rich post.


  • Steamhead
    Steamhead Member Posts: 16,889
    Unfortunately for Mr. Clifton

    most people are not going to spend the money for anything more than a tank-type replacement heater that does not require any new or modified gas piping, water piping, venting or wiring. That's the reality.

    And since an EnergyStar-qualified tank-type heater is 15% more efficient than a standard one, these are the models we offer- specifically, Bradford-White M4 series units. Mr. Clifton can deride EnergyStar from his high horse as much as he wants, but it has achieved a significant increase in available tank-type heater efficiency. 15% is not chump change with today's gas prices. I would assume EnergyStar standards for water heaters will be raised at some point, and at least some manufacturers will be able to meet them.

    We also recommend installing a sediment filter on every incoming water service where we replace a water heater. This keeps sediment out of the bottom of the tank, so the tank lasts longer and the heat-transfer surface doesn't get blocked, helping to maintain the unit's efficiency over time.

    Our upgrades away from tank-type gas water heaters are usually indirects.
    All Steamed Up, Inc.
    Towson, MD, USA
    Steam, Vapor & Hot-Water Heating Specialists
    Oil & Gas Burner Service
This discussion has been closed.