Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.
Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

If you've found help here, check back in to let us know how everything worked out.
It's a great way to thank those who helped you.
Need to contact us? Visit



Last Active


  • Jamie Hall
    True enough in general that most older houses are over radiated -- up to a point. Really old houses, for various reasons, tend not to be. The principle place I care for -- Cedric's home -- has a total of 1400 EDR in radiation. Cedric and the radiation -- fired at 2.75 gph -- can only just keep up when it's really cold out! (defined around here as -10 F).
    September 8
    • mikeg2015
      The big wild card is infiltration on 2 story or taller homes. Retrofits such as venting a previously unvented attic (for the record, I think vented attic are a stupid concept built on a myth, that needs to go away) for example, can be a killer. As the home settles and window sashes wear infiltration can really pick up.

      That being said, unless your really “on the edge” on sizing, the very limited run time for an indirect should have negligible impact. But you have to try and evaluate each home individually, but I wouldn’t use any hard rule.]

      150 gallons of hot water use with a 70F temp rise, is 52 minutes at 100k BTU indirect input. That would be on hte higher end I think for water use in all reality. That’s 1 hour at 2.5 GPM.

      Keep in mind that in your example, -10F is in fact probably 5F colder than design temperature and a home should start “losing ground” just a little since it’s a <1% condition. Design in SE Iowa here is 2F. In Michigan, despite being further north for example it’s temepered by the lakes so design was +5F or higher in some locations. Plus here the coldest days, Though windy are also almost always sunny during the day, so you recover by late morning.
  • mikeg2015 and Frankcreo_777 earned the Photogenic badge.
    Little things like uploading a profile picture make the community a better place. Thanks!
    September 1
  • mikeg2015 earned the 5 LOLs badge.
    You received 5 LOLs. We like that.
    August 26


It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


Photogenic5 LOLs5 Awesomes25 Agrees25 LikesSecond Anniversary500 CommentsFirst Anniversary5 Agrees5 Likes100 CommentsName Dropper10 CommentsFirst Comment